Residents who listened to Friday night’s District 3 forum witnessed a supervisor race speeding toward a conservative endpoint, with five candidates poised to replace Supervisor Aaron Peskin often collectively supporting tough-on-crime measures and police commission reforms while opposing reparations for Black Americans.
The sixth candidate, Wendy Ha Chau, didn’t attend the forum.
The direction was led by candidate Matt Susk, who previously worked in private real estate and who is endorsed by organizations like the big-money groups Neighbors for a Better San Francisco and ConnectedSF, which is largely funded by Neighbors; San Francisco Association of Realtors; and the San Francisco Police Officers Association.
Among the three leading candidates, Sen. Scott Wiener’s pick, Danny Sauter, occasionally emerged as the more progressive voice on stage, surpassing his two Peskin-endorsed competitors. He was the strongest pro-reparations voice, for example, among the candidates. The latter includes Moe Jamil, a deputy city attorney, and a self-identified “non-YIMBY moderate,” and Sharon Lai, a former board member at the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency, who perceives herself as being at the “center in the San Francisco spectrum of politics.”
The candidates appeared to be playing to a less progressive base in the room. Some 200 audience members, mostly Chinese-speaking seniors, participated at the Friday debate at the Chinese Culture Center on Kearny Street.
For one thing, none of the five candidates expressed support for the reparations proposal for the descendants of slaves in San Francisco, an option that was put off the table for the city at the end of last year. District 3 has one of the lowest percentages of Black residents — only 3.85 percent of the population.
Susk started off with a staunch objection to reparations. “I still haven’t fully understood … why San Francisco would be on the hook to pay out over $1 billion to folks here,” he said, adding that reparations are “something I wanted to study more.”
Jamil proposed to focus on anti-gentrification and anti-displacement strategies instead of reparations, candidate Eduard Navarro questioned the effectiveness of reparations, and Lai pitched for providing more education and vocational training opportunities.
Sauter was the only one who explicitly stated that San Francisco needs to take responsibility for the country’s history of forced enslavement. “San Francisco itself is not immune to an ugly past and ugly history,” he said, acknowledging that though some of the recommendations by the Reparations Task Force are difficult to implement, “there are some that can be implemented and should be implemented quite quickly.”
Four of the five candidates who attended Friday’s forum support Proposition 36, a November California ballot measure that would roll back portions of Prop. 47, allowing felony charges for thefts under $950 and possessing certain drugs if the person has two past theft or drug convictions.
“We have to be careful of the progressive echo chamber,” said Jamil. “We need to make sure that people do not come to San Francisco to commit those crimes,” said Susk.
Navarro declined to address Prop. 36 directly. Instead, he elaborated on the specific penalties for felonies and misdemeanors. “I don’t know that it’s the nature of the punishment that really incentivizes somebody not to commit the crime,” he said. He called for a more holistic examination of the situation, mentioning trade-offs including prison populations, cost of the state and the impact of incarceration track record on people’s life.
“What is not true is that stealing less than $950 is free,” he said.
Similarly, when asked whether the San Francisco police commission has too much power, three candidates supported reforming the commission. Navarro declined to elaborate his ideas for the commission, while Lai emphasized the importance of competent commissioners.
The commission came under attack last year after one of Mayor London Breed’s appointees, commissioner Max Carter-Oberstone, failed to support Breed’s proposal to expand police powers and potentially curtail the commission’s power. Prop. E passed in March and loosened police rules; Lai was the only one among the five candidates who voted against it. Prop. D on November’s ballot would further weaken the police commission, as it would give the police chief sole authority to adopt rules governing police officers’ conduct.
Jamil called for a “wholesale change on the police commission” to improve morale. “I think the commission has gone way too overboard on micromanaging,” he said. Jamil is endorsed by Debra Walker, a police commissioner who faced pushback earlier this year because of doubts regarding her commitment to the commission’s oversight mandate.
Susk went one step further, proposing to add police officers to the commission that’s tasked with overseeing those same officers. “I will make sure that one retired officer is put on the police commission and one active duty officer is put on” the commission, he said. In fact, only the mayor or a majority of supervisors have the power to appoint to the police commission.
The debate was organized by the Coalition for Community Safety and Justice, and moderated by Sarah Wan, the executive director of Community Youth Center, and Joyce Lam of the Chinese Progressive Association.
Candidates generally agreed with each other on most issues including community safety, supporting victims and Chinatown residents. The almost only notable discord arose when Lai pressed Sauter for a response about his acceptance of $4,000 from Govern for California, which is currently under state investigation for bundling donations. Sauter ignored Lai’s question.
During the rest of the night, Susk firmly and comfortably went down the conservative path as a way to differentiate himself. He proposed stopping any program to give affordable housing to “people who are addicted to fentanyl without abstinence requirements,” blamed San Francisco for vilifying tech companies, pitched to make sure people pay for the buses “so that people feel safe,” and expressed strong disapproval of the San Francisco Bicycle Coalition.
“We cannot let the Bike Coalition continue to control our streets and shut down every street in this city one by one,” he said.
In comparison, Jamil leaned progressive on issues like tenants rights. Still, one incident that has been discussed in Discuss 3 was his wording in a recent forum, which echoed Donald Trump.
“I want to erect, almost a wall, on the district line to make sure that those encampments and drug dealers, and whatnot are not in District 3,” said Jamil in an Aug. 24 forum.
“I used the metaphor of a wall as a way to illustrate the degree to which I will protect the safety of the people of District 3. I clearly didn’t mean building a physical wall,” Jamil wrote in a Tuesday newsletter to supporters in response to questions from competitors and voters. Despite the controversy, Jamil’s main endorser, District 3 incumbent supervisor and progressive leader Peskin, still presented at events with Jamil.
Jamil’s competitors apparently think otherwise. Sauter believes “an authentic apology” is still necessary, “especially given what we’re seeing on the national level right now, it’s very ugly rhetoric and it’s dangerous rhetoric.”
“It’s dangerous and unhelpful to the community to use words that could incite actions that are not inclusive,” said Lai.
Recently, the similarity of Lai and Sauter’s positions on many issues has sparked rumors that they are partnering for the ranked-choice election. The speculation has been further fueled by some recent endorsements that have chosen both of them, including those from the Alice B. Toklas LGBTQ Democratic Club and the San Francisco Young Democrats.
Although negotiations between campaigns have been taking place, candidates confirmed, none of the five candidates have decided their ranked-choice strategy.
The only exceptions are Sauter and Jamil, who are mutually exclusive to each other. “I can’t imagine myself working with Moe,” said Sauter, while Jamil stated, “No alliance with Danny.”
About the author
Jim’s, Mission diner, will keep cooking under nonprofit ownership
Fear not, we won’t be missing the beloved green salsa at Jim’s Restaurant for some time — breakfast is here to stay. Mission Local has learned that the Mission Language and Vocational School will take over neighborhood mainstay Jim’s, which invited customers in today for its last day in business under current ownership. This afternoon, a line was seen reaching the corner of the building at 20th and Mission streets, and the diner had to take a waitlist for people to get in. Mission Language and Vocational School, a nonprofit that offers workforce development and small business supportive services, will staff the restaurant with graduates from its catering program and culinary school. The nonprofit will keep on Beto, the longtime cook. The owners, husband and wife Kim Ok Un and Kim Jung Nyun, are retiring. MLVS is expected to take over the restaurant […]
Lara Trump withdraws from consideration to replace Rubio in US Senate
By Jasper Ward(Reuters) -Lara Trump, daughter-in-law of President-elect Donald Trump, said on Saturday she has removed her name from consideration to replace outgoing U.S. Senator Marco Rubio.Rubio was picked by Trump to serve as secretary of state. Florida Governor Ron DeSantis will pick a replacement for Rubio, who is expected to resign as senator when Trump takes office on Jan. 20.There was speculation that Lara Trump, who served as co-chair of the Republican National Committee in the lead-up to the 2024 election, would succeed Rubio in the Senate.Trusted news and daily delights, right in your inboxSee for yourself — The Yodel is the go-to source for daily news, entertainment and feel-good stories.However, in a post on X, Trump said she had decided to remove herself from consideration "after an incredible amount of thought, contemplation, and encouragement from so many.""I could […]
Hawk on the house
Hawk on the house Source: missionlocal.org
Burglars ransack Southern California homes while posing as deliverymen
Residents are frightened and angry as a group of suspects continue ransacking San Fernando Valley homes, leaving a trail of destruction behind.A Valley Village resident said she was stunned and shaken up after thieves targeted her home on Dec. 17 between 5 p.m. to 6 p.m.The break-in was captured on home surveillance cameras as a male suspect approached the house and appeared to be disguised as a delivery man.“Ten minutes after we left [our home], someone was knocking at the door and our dog was barking away,” she said. “Then within a minute, someone had broken into the back of the house, smashed the glass door, came in and locked the dog in a room and just trashed the house. They took all of my jewelry.”Photos of the aftermath showed drawers in every room were removed and emptied and all […]
Jim’s owners retiring, leaving future of Mission diner unclear
The mom-and-pop owners of Jim’s Restaurant on Mission Street, a community staple for over three decades, will have their last day of work this Saturday, according to the restaurant.Jim’s Restaurant announced that its owners will be retiring after Saturday. It’s unclear, however, whether Jim’s will continue operating under new management. What is clear is it will no longer be the same without Ms. and Mr. Kim. The current owners, Kim Ok Un and Kim Jung Nyun, declined to comment about their retirement or whether Jim’s would continue operating. An Instagram commenter says, “So so sooo happy for you guys!! So well deserved but Jim’s will never be the same without you”.Another says, “Legendary spot just up the street from KPOO. Thanks y’all for the decades of service to the community.”On Friday around noon, the restaurant at 2420 Mission St. between 20th and […]
Police bust man at Gwinnett McDonald’s they say tried to sell home he didn’t own
Gwinnett County police arrested a man at a local McDonald’s who they say attempted to sell a property he did not own by stealing the identity of its rightful owner.Police say 55-year-old Armond Long, of Lilburn, posed as the property owner and listed the land for sale on Zillow.The scheme unraveled when the actual owner discovered the listing while the sale was pending and contacted authorities.Records show the land was pending for $130,000 before law enforcement got involved.“He didn’t have any intention of selling that property, so he contacted local authorities,” said Cpl. Juan Madiedo.TRENDING STORIES: Authorities in Lake Havasu City, Arizona worked with Gwinnett County police to set up a sting operation.Long agreed to meet at a McDonald’s near the Mall of Georgia to sign final closing documents. An undercover Gwinnett officer, posing as a courier, handed Long documents […]
Related
Jim’s, Mission diner, will keep cooking under nonprofit ownership
Fear not, we won’t be missing the beloved green salsa at Jim’s Restaurant for some time — breakfast is here to stay. Mission Local has learned that the Mission Language and Vocational School will take over neighborhood mainstay Jim’s, which invited customers in today for its last day in business under current ownership. This afternoon, a line was seen reaching the corner of the building at 20th and Mission streets, and the diner had to take a waitlist for people to get in. Mission Language and Vocational School, a nonprofit that offers workforce development and small business supportive services, will staff the restaurant with graduates from its catering program and culinary school. The nonprofit will keep on Beto, the longtime cook. The owners, husband and wife Kim Ok Un and Kim Jung Nyun, are retiring. MLVS is expected to take over the restaurant […]
Hawk on the house
Hawk on the house Source: missionlocal.org
Jim’s owners retiring, leaving future of Mission diner unclear
The mom-and-pop owners of Jim’s Restaurant on Mission Street, a community staple for over three decades, will have their last day of work this Saturday, according to the restaurant.Jim’s Restaurant announced that its owners will be retiring after Saturday. It’s unclear, however, whether Jim’s will continue operating under new management. What is clear is it will no longer be the same without Ms. and Mr. Kim. The current owners, Kim Ok Un and Kim Jung Nyun, declined to comment about their retirement or whether Jim’s would continue operating. An Instagram commenter says, “So so sooo happy for you guys!! So well deserved but Jim’s will never be the same without you”.Another says, “Legendary spot just up the street from KPOO. Thanks y’all for the decades of service to the community.”On Friday around noon, the restaurant at 2420 Mission St. between 20th and […]
S.F. police shoot, kill Dior guard turned alleged hit-and-run driver
San Francisco police shot and killed a purportedly armed man they say they tracked down — after he allegedly hit pedestrians and a cyclist with a car on Thursday evening. Assistant Chief David Lazar, who gave a press conference this morning, said the man was believed to be a security guard at Dior, and said he discovered a firearm “on the ground” at the scene that he believed belonged to the guard. He did not give any details about whether the man was armed at the time police shot him. Lazar also could not confirm how many police officers fired their weapons at the man. The driver was allegedly driving on the sidewalk around 6:30 p.m. at Kearny and Post streets and hit two pedestrians, an 18-year-old and a 17-year-old, Lazar said, in pursuit of a man on an electric bicycle. After hitting […]
Street sheet – Mission Local
Mission Local produces enterprise reporting on San Francisco's most critical issues: police reform, corruption, public health, housing and homelessness. Learn more about us, and donate below keep us reporting.Subscribe to Mission Local's daily newsletter Source: missionlocal.org
Supervisor Melgar won, now the trick will be to manage her constituents’ competing interests
District 7 incumbent Myrna Melgar faced a particularly bruising re-election campaign. She squared off against significant numbers of her own constituents by supporting hot-button issues like Proposition K to close the Great Highway to cars, and upzoning parts of her district that have been previously limited to single-family housing. “If I lose this election on this issue, then that’s the right thing to do,” Melgar said in June, after a particularly contentious meeting about zoning changes coming to her district, and the rest of the city. But she didn’t lose the election. No matter the ideological differences, most of her constituents agree: She’s good at the actual work of being a district supervisor. “When I call — somebody does get back to me,” said Peggy da Silva, a West Portal resident who has reached out to Melgar’s office over concerns like city […]
