In response to public outcry over bystander video of police wrestling with a struggling female hot dog vendor, San Francisco Police Chief Bill Scott said on Wednesday that he expects to release the involved officers’ body-worn camera footage.
Scott said he saw no wrongdoing by the police after reviewing all the body-worn camera footage from the officers who were involved in a back-and-forth between the woman, who was selling hot dogs near Pier 33, and city workers who were attempting to confiscate her cart.
“There is nothing that I saw in this video that officers or anybody else involved did anything other than what they were asked to do, in the way that they were asked to do it,” Scott said before the Police Commission on Wednesday. “I saw nothing that indicated misconduct.”
Ana Luisa Casimer Julca, the 25-year-old pregnant woman who was accused of assaulting Port of San Francisco workers during the confiscation of her cart, maintains that she didn’t assault anyone.
“I will say this, It was not an assaultive struggle,” Scott said of the initial dispute. “It was just a struggle over control of the cart because she did not want to give up her cart.”
But Scott said that videos of the arrest that circulated the internet — which show two officers pinning Casimer Julca to the ground while her daughter screams and cries — “does not tell the story.” He described to police commissioners step by step what he saw happen on officers’ body-worn cameras.
The footage of the arrest obtained and published by Mission Local commences with two officers already on the pavement atop Casimer Julca near Pier 33 after an attempted confiscation of her cart by Port workers.
What occurred prior may become clear with the new footage, which Scott said he expects to release by next week.
An SFPD spokesperson told Mission Local at the time that Casimer Julca obstructed and assaulted a Port employee, and was therefore arrested for assault on a government employee and resisting or delaying an investigation.
Casimer Julca, however, told Mission Local she did not assault the worker — she seemed eager to see additional footage of the incident.
A struggle over a cart
Scott said that around 9:30 a.m. on Sept. 8, members of the multi-department task force, led by the Port of San Francisco and accompanied by workers from the Department of Public Works and the Department of Public Health, warned food vendors to leave the area.
The SFPD, in a statement on Tuesday, said the group gave warnings around 10:30 a.m. Casimer Julca, however, said that she arrived shortly after 11 that day, and never received any warning.
Scott said the task force members returned to the Pier 33 area around 11:30 a.m. to find “at least three” hot dog vendors there. One cart — Casimer Julca’s — was tagged for impoundment by the Department of Public Health. That’s when the conversation became contentious, Scott said. A struggle over the cart ensued, and officers intervened to defuse the situation and separate Casimer Julca from her cart.
This separation did not last; as workers attempted to impound the cart, Scott said Casimer Julca evaded the police officers and returned to her cart, when another struggle ensued. During that struggle, the cart was knocked over, and Scott said Casimer Julca pushed one Port employee “to try to get him off of the cart,” while the other got cut on his hand.
“That’s when the officers decided to place her in handcuffs,” Scott said, “to get control of the situation.” When Casimer Julca resisted, he added, “the officers ended up … taking her down to the ground.”
Casimer Julca said she refused to let go of the cart, even when it fell to the ground, but learned the reason for her arrest later, when a Spanish speaking officer arrived: “I supposedly assaulted the Port [employee] at some point,” she said in Spanish.
“But no, I didn’t do anything to him,” she said. “We were just grabbing the cart, [telling him] that ‘Please, please don’t take it from me,’ and nothing else.”
Scott said he knows people are trying to make a living by vending in the street, but that the city receives demands to control rampant unpermitted vending. Police don’t enforce vending rules, but are present as security during vending enforcement operations by other city departments. Those workers have reported facing violence and harassment while attempting to enforce vending rules around the city.
Casimer Julca, for her part, said she has been trying to find more video footage of the incident, because she doesn’t think she did anything wrong.
“It’s not fair that they say I attacked him so they can handcuff me,” she said.
As a recent immigrant from Peru, she said she didn’t understand what the city workers were telling her in English, but acknowledged trying to prevent them from taking her cart, which cost her about $600 and which she has only had for two months. She said she is also two months pregnant.
Now, she said she feels bruised all over, particularly in her arms and shoulders, and is taking medication for the pain.
Scott confirmed on Wednesday that a Spanish speaking city employee arrived to converse with Casimer Julca, but only after the struggle had ended with her being cuffed.
On Tuesday, the SFPD put out a statement on Twitter alleging that the video footage of the arrest was released to the media as part of an “orchestrated effort by people illegally vending hot dogs to undermine the city’s efforts to enforce the law.”
Footage obtained by Mission Local was from a bystander who has no connection to the vendors.
“The combination of the crying child with her mother on the ground being handcuffed created a dramatic moment that was carefully edited,” the police statement said.
Police Commission President Cindy Elias seemed to agree it didn’t look good.
“At the end of the day, what you see is … a child, a woman of color,” Elias said of the video. “Although you are here to tell us what you’ve seen, I think the public needs to see it for themselves.”
About the author
Before Implosion, “Titan ”Pilot and CEO Had Panicked Meltdown When He Crashed Into a Shipwreck: Ex-Employee
"It was unprofessional behavior of him, he started to panic," David Lochridge testified of Stockton RushYears before he piloted the Titan submersible more than 2 miles beneath the surface of the Northern Atlantic Ocean on a doomed voyage to see the wreckage of the Titanic, Stockton Rush took another small group of passengers to see another famed ship beneath the waves — but fell into “panic” due to a lack of experience, a former employee claims.David Lochridge, who worked as operations director at OceanGate, which Rush co-founded and ran as CEO, testified on Tuesday, Sept. 17, at an ongoing U.S. Coast Guard hearing about the implosion of Titan while on its way to the Titanic last summer, killing all five people aboard, including Rush.Lochridge did not mince words about his views on Rush or OceanGate.“The whole idea behind the company […]
Vea cómo se postulan: Los demócratas de SF acusan a Mark Farrell de utilizar indebidamente el logotipo de apoyo del partido
Read in EnglishMission Local está publicando artículos de campaña para cada una/uno de los principales contendientes en la carrera por la alcaldía, alternando entre los candidatos semanalmente hasta noviembre. Esta semana: Mark Farrell. Lea los artículos anteriores aquí.El Partido Demócrata de San Francisco ha acusado al candidato a la alcaldía, Mark Farrell, de utilizar indebidamente su logotipo en un folleto sobre la Propuesta D enviado a los votantes la semana pasada. El correo en cuestión, de 20 por 30 centímetros, muestra de forma destacada una foto de Farrell y una cita de su apoyo a la Propuesta D, la medida para limitar las comisiones municipales, junto al logotipo del SF Dems en un círculo azul oscuro, muy similar al sello de apoyo del partido.Aunque el partido ha respaldado la Proposición D, no ha respaldado a Farrell – ese honor fue para […]
Absentee in-person voting starts in early October in Ottawa County
Oct. 7 is the closing date for new voter registrations and changes of address and names for the Nov. 5 general election.Regular office hours are 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Monday through Friday. The Board of Elections will be open Oct. 7 until 9 p.m. The Ottawa County office is located at 8444 West Ohio 163, Oak Harbor.More: Ohio Secretary of State highlights election securityNew registrations and changes of address and name may also be made at any public library; any Bureau of Motor Vehicles office; the Ottawa County Health Department; and at the Ottawa County Courthouse at the Clerk of Courts Title Department or the Treasurer’s office. Change of address may be completed at www.VoteOhio.gov.Ohio Issue 1 2024: What is it? Would it stop gerrymandering?Absentee in-person voting starts Oct. 8 at 8 a.m. and ends Nov. 3 at 5 […]
Mayor Breed is deleting texts. Legal experts say that’s a problem.
On June 29, Mayor London Breed texted Carla Short, the director of San Francisco Public Works, asking her to send out a crew to pick up trash in the Tenderloin.“I’m at Azalina’s. Are you around? You should stop by,” read the text from Breed, sent at 5:54 p.m. while the mayor was at a Malaysian restaurant near Ellis and Leavenworth streets. “Can you send someone to clean up across the street please. It [sic] a pile of trash on the south west corner.”Short said she was at a Giants game but promised to “send someone now.” “That would be great,” Breed wrote in response. “I want her to succeed but the tents and trash are a problem,” she added, seemingly referencing a homeless woman on the corner. “We will deal with the tents. Thank you and enjoy the game.” That simple […]
Final messages revealed from the Titan sub before tragic implosion
“All good here.”Those were some of the final words that the doomed Titan submersible crew communicated before the submersible imploded on its mission to the Titanic wreckage site in June 2023.The message, revealed as part of the Coast Guard’s Monday hearing into the circumstances of the failed mission, was sent to support vessel Polar Prince on June 18, 2023, shortly before the submersible imploded, killing all five of its crew members. It was an incident that captivated both sides of the Atlantic as crews made a mad dash to save the crew after the sub lost contact with the surface - with the world unaware that the lives had been lost.The Coast Guard played an animated re-enactment of the Titan’s voyage that captured the submersible’s final, spotty exchange with the Polar Prince, during the Monday hearing that shed new light […]
Wells Fargo sign blows loose; firefighters on scene
Sign up below to get Mission Local’s free newsletter, a daily digest of news you won’t find elsewhere. The corner of Mission and 22nd has been sealed off and firefighters have ascended a ladder to remove a Wells Fargo sign overlooking the intersection, which came loose during a gusty day. Earlier in the evening, pedestrians were asked to avoid the vicinity in the event the large red-and-yellow bank sign fell. Building representatives were also on scene, and the fire department said it was opening to securing or removing the sign. They chose the latter, with the property owner’s permission. “This is an isolated hazard and we ask that you avoid the area,” the fire department added in a statement, advising travelers to plan alternative routes. Want the latest on the Mission and San Francisco? Sign up for our free daily […]
Related
Vea cómo se postulan: Los demócratas de SF acusan a Mark Farrell de utilizar indebidamente el logotipo de apoyo del partido
Read in EnglishMission Local está publicando artículos de campaña para cada una/uno de los principales contendientes en la carrera por la alcaldía, alternando entre los candidatos semanalmente hasta noviembre. Esta semana: Mark Farrell. Lea los artículos anteriores aquí.El Partido Demócrata de San Francisco ha acusado al candidato a la alcaldía, Mark Farrell, de utilizar indebidamente su logotipo en un folleto sobre la Propuesta D enviado a los votantes la semana pasada. El correo en cuestión, de 20 por 30 centímetros, muestra de forma destacada una foto de Farrell y una cita de su apoyo a la Propuesta D, la medida para limitar las comisiones municipales, junto al logotipo del SF Dems en un círculo azul oscuro, muy similar al sello de apoyo del partido.Aunque el partido ha respaldado la Proposición D, no ha respaldado a Farrell – ese honor fue para […]
Mayor Breed is deleting texts. Legal experts say that’s a problem.
On June 29, Mayor London Breed texted Carla Short, the director of San Francisco Public Works, asking her to send out a crew to pick up trash in the Tenderloin.“I’m at Azalina’s. Are you around? You should stop by,” read the text from Breed, sent at 5:54 p.m. while the mayor was at a Malaysian restaurant near Ellis and Leavenworth streets. “Can you send someone to clean up across the street please. It [sic] a pile of trash on the south west corner.”Short said she was at a Giants game but promised to “send someone now.” “That would be great,” Breed wrote in response. “I want her to succeed but the tents and trash are a problem,” she added, seemingly referencing a homeless woman on the corner. “We will deal with the tents. Thank you and enjoy the game.” That simple […]
Wells Fargo sign blows loose; firefighters on scene
Sign up below to get Mission Local’s free newsletter, a daily digest of news you won’t find elsewhere. The corner of Mission and 22nd has been sealed off and firefighters have ascended a ladder to remove a Wells Fargo sign overlooking the intersection, which came loose during a gusty day. Earlier in the evening, pedestrians were asked to avoid the vicinity in the event the large red-and-yellow bank sign fell. Building representatives were also on scene, and the fire department said it was opening to securing or removing the sign. They chose the latter, with the property owner’s permission. “This is an isolated hazard and we ask that you avoid the area,” the fire department added in a statement, advising travelers to plan alternative routes. Want the latest on the Mission and San Francisco? Sign up for our free daily […]
United Dumplings: A Bernal Heights delight
The original United Dumplings has been on Cortland in Bernal since late 2020, but my first time trying their food was just last year at their Oakland location. Women-owned, United Dumplings offers a mix of tradition and innovation, and it all tastes authentically great. I was blown away by the quality of the dumplings and the variety of offerings — of not just dumplings but the myriad noodles, rice, veggie, and tofu options. I was overjoyed to learn (very belatedly) that we had one so close to the Mission. The original is a bit more casual and spare than its East Bay cousin, but the menus seem to be identical. (There’s also another outpost in the Marina.)Pea shoots I tried in Oakland were a favorite, so I had to have them here.Pea ShootsThey were so abundantly garlicky, and so lusciously creamy, they almost seemed […]
Controller assumes de facto control of Human Rights Commission
In a Friday afternoon letter to San Francisco officials, city controller Greg Wagner announced his office would essentially assume control of the scandal-plagued Human Rights Commission, with his “accounting staff immediately to oversee accounting operations at HRC, including approvals of payments and other financial transactions.”The Human Rights Commission’s director, Sheryl Davis, resigned at Mayor London Breed’s behest yesterday and hired a defense attorney after a slew of news articles alleging cavalier or even potentially illegal spending.The San Francisco Chronicle on Thursday revealed that Davis spent some $10,000 renting a home for city interns on Martha’s Vineyard, allegedly splitting the invoice to evade city reporting requirements for purchases of $10,000 or more. On the same day, the San Francisco Standard noted that Davis had directed some $1.5 million in funding to the nonprofit Collective Impact, which is overseen by James Spignola. […]
San Francisco District 3 debate filled by conservative voices
Residents who listened to Friday night’s District 3 forum witnessed a supervisor race speeding toward a conservative endpoint, with five candidates poised to replace Supervisor Aaron Peskin often collectively supporting tough-on-crime measures and police commission reforms while opposing reparations for Black Americans. The sixth candidate, Wendy Ha Chau, didn’t attend the forum.The direction was led by candidate Matt Susk, who previously worked in private real estate and who is endorsed by organizations like the big-money groups Neighbors for a Better San Francisco and ConnectedSF, which is largely funded by Neighbors; San Francisco Association of Realtors; and the San Francisco Police Officers Association. Among the three leading candidates, Sen. Scott Wiener’s pick, Danny Sauter, occasionally emerged as the more progressive voice on stage, surpassing his two Peskin-endorsed competitors. He was the strongest pro-reparations voice, for example, among the candidates. The latter includes Moe […]
Be the first to leave a comment