The Sunshine Ordinance Task Force, San Francisco’s oversight body responsible for public records and transparency laws, unanimously ruled on Wednesday night that Mayor London Breed and City Attorney David Chiu both violated city law by deleting text messages dealing with official business.
The eight members of the task force in attendance — two were absent, one seat is vacant — also unanimously referred the mayor’s actions to the San Francisco Ethics Commission for investigation and possible discipline.
“This seems like such an egregious practice,” said Dean Schmidt, an attorney and task force member. “This is a person who’s probably constantly sending messages around the city, and yet … none of them are making it to the public record. I mean that is a quantum violation, in my estimation, of public records laws.”
“It means everything’s been deleted,” Schmidt continued, indicating not just a “negligent” approach or “carelessness,” he said, but “willful” deletion. “Someone is saying to the rest of us: ‘Screw you, I’m not going to show you any of my texts.’”
Mission Local first reported on the mayor’s practice of deleting texts in mid-September, after the Sunshine task force heard of the practice at a hearing on Aug. 20. Mission Local spoke to half a dozen public records experts who said the practice likely violates California state law requiring retaining records for two years.
At the Wednesday hearing, the task force was ruling on a complaint brought forth by Hazel Williams, an activist and public records filer who regularly requests text messages from Breed.
Williams had uncovered the text deletion practice after she requested the most recent texts from Breed — that is, any text message whatsoever dealing with city business. Public officials are required to preserve official records, even if on personal phones; Breed uses her personal phone for work.
While Williams recovered a text discussion between Public Works head Carla Short and Breed via Public Works, Breed’s office said the mayor had no text messages responsive to the requests — indicating Breed routinely deleted them. In part citing a 1995 city attorney memo, the mayor’s office has argued that text messages are not “records” for the sake of public records law, and that Breed and other mayoral staff can choose to delete them.
On Wednesday, the mayor’s legal compliance officer said that the key question, for retention purposes, is whether communications “memorialize an official action” or are “official evidence” of city activities. Public records attorneys have said that’s too narrow a view.
Williams this summer also requested text messages from City Attorney David Chiu to Breed; Chiu’s office said they had none. She then brought both cases to the Sunshine task force for investigation.
The task force pointed to the Sunshine Ordinance under San Francisco Administrative Code §67.29-7, which states that “the Mayor and all Department Heads” should keep “all documents and correspondence,” and lists as examples “letters, emails, drafts” and other records.
The ordinance, under §67.34, also states that the “willful failure” of elected officials or department heads to follow the Sunshine Ordinance “shall be deemed official misconduct” to be “handled by the Ethics Commission.” The task force referred Breed’s practice to the Ethics Commission under that section.
In a statement sent Thursday, Jen Kwart, the city attorney’s spokesperson, who spoke at the hearing on Wednesday, said the task force’s ruling “simply does not have a basis in the law.”
“The law doesn’t require that every document that could be subject to disclosure must be retained for two years,” the statement read. “It is disappointing that the Task Force chose to ignore a California Attorney General opinion and over 40 years of established practice.”
During the hearing, however, commissioners made it clear: They are disturbed by the practice of officials deleting text messages, and perplexed by the legal arguments from the mayor and city attorney.
“If she occasionally uses her phone to text for city business, shouldn’t there have been something on her phone?” asked Lila LaHood, a Sunshine task force member and the executive director of the nonprofit San Francisco Public Press, speaking to Hank Heckel, the mayor’s legal compliance officer.
Heckel said the mayor had no text messages.
“So you’re saying she’s deleting the messages that pertain to city business?” LaHood continued.
“I don’t know,” Heckel said — Breed could be deleting text messages, he said, or she could have “gotten a new phone” and the texts were lost. That would indicate that Breed is getting a new phone every day, as Williams has requested texts from her office every day since Aug. 29.
As long as the text messages do not have “ongoing significance,” Breed is free to delete them, Heckel added. In the past, Heckel pointed to a 2014 retention policy that the office has interpreted as allowing the mayor and her staff to delete routine communications.
“Honestly, the only thing that you’ve said that makes sense to me is maybe she got a new phone, because everything else doesn’t,” LaHood replied. “It doesn’t make sense to me that somebody would systematically delete all of their messages … I’m baffled.”
Earlier in the hearing, when Kwart from the city attorney’s office spoke, she likened Chiu’s deletion of texts to “good phone hygiene” because the texts are not substantive — Chiu and Breed text “about once a month,” she said, sending messages along the lines of “Hey, can I call you?” Those texts, she added, Chiu deletes.
“I find it quite suspicious, the idea from both parties today … that it’s like, ‘Oh well, for good housekeeping, we’re deleting these minor text messages between two departments,” said Saul Sugarman, a task force member and the editor in chief of the Bold Italic. Like the other seven commissioners present, he voted to find both Breed and Chiu in violation.
“I think that’s an excellent point,” replied Matt Yankee, who has years of experience working for different Bay Area city governments and chairs the commission. The texts, several commissioners said, frequently deal with city business, like directing staff to do police enforcement or clean-up operations.
Public records experts told Mission Local that the officials’ deletion practice opens the city up to litigation, and it is unclear the practice will change without a lawsuit, since the mayor’s office and city attorney’s office both hold that texts do not rise to the level of an official public record.
In only referring the mayor’s deletion to the Ethics Commission, the task force members noted that Breed’s practice is not new: In 2020, Williams first publicized a trove of text messages between Breed and staff in which she personally directed them to clean up street trash and homeless encampments.
Since then, Williams said she has not received any text messages from the mayor.
The fact that the mayor has not turned over texts since 2020, said Yankee, indicated a practice of “Don’t save ‘em on the phone anymore. If you are going to send ‘em out, delete ‘em real fast.”
This year, Williams has requested the mayor’s latest text messages every single day, at midnight, since Aug. 29.
Breed’s office has responded to her with the same, simple message: “The Office of the Mayor has performed a reasonable and diligent search in response to your request. We have not located any responsive records.”
About the author
Danny Sauter, set to win District 3, had area-wide appeal
Danny Sauter leads the District 3 Supervisor race with 56 percent of the votes, leading his closest challenger Sharon Lai by 1,821 votes, according to the latest results.Though another 157,000 votes remain to be counted, ranked-choice voting experts said Sauter is unlikely to lose his commanding lead. For Lai to win, the remaining votes “would have to be very, very different to what we’ve seen so far. They have to be much more pro-Sharon,” said Jason McDaniel, San Francisco State University political science professor with a research focus on ranked-choice voting.“I don’t see that happening,” he added. Note: These results are preliminary. Table created by Kelly Waldron. Data released by the San Francisco Department of Elections on Nov. 6 at 1 a.m. Sauter, who at 36 would be one of the youngest members of the Board of Supervisors, was endorsed by […]
Mysterious black balls that washed up on Sydney beach were foul-smelling mini ‘fatbergs’
The mystery of the black balls that washed up on some of Sydney’s most iconic beaches last month has now been solved – and it’s more disgusting than you could ever imagine.Australian beachgoers were turned away from seven beaches last month after lifeguards spotted thousands of black spheres, prompting closures and clean-up efforts.A team of scientists at the University of New South Wales (UNSW) has revealed the black balls – initially thought to be made of tar – were actually mini “fatbergs,” made up of human feces, methamphetamine, human hair, fatty acids, and food waste, among hundreds of other vile and befuddling substances.“They smell absolutely disgusting, they smell worse than anything you’ve ever smelt,” lead investigator Associate Professor Jon Beves told CNN affiliate 9News.The New South Wales Environment Protection Authority (EPA) first warned Sydney residents to avoid swimming or touching […]
Daniel Lurie leads after strange and terrible election night: Analysis
It’s a shame that San Francisco’s fascinating election results can’t be viewed in isolation from the strange and terrible returns that propelled Donald Trump once more to the presidency. But the luxury of ignoring the bigger picture is something San Francisco no longer gets to do. As of a shade before 1 a.m., every last in-person vote was tabulated — 37,345 of them (20,000 provisional votes are pending). In-person voting is a bit like shaving with a straight-edge razor or knitting your own pot-holders: You could do it if you wanted to, but hardly anybody does. At present, 234,453 votes have been counted; a shade under 45 percent. The Department of Elections expects around 157,000 more votes to trickle in (including those 20,000 provisional ballots). That would result in perhaps a 75 percent turnout; San Francisco voters show up at an average […]
Gov. Tim Walz will face new era of divided government in Minnesota
MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — Gov. Tim Walz faces a new era of divided government when he returns home from the presidential campaign trail, now that Republicans appear to have broken the Democratic trifecta that helped put him on Kamala Harris’ radar.While Democrats will keep their one-seat majority in the Senate, leaders on both sides agree that Republicans gained enough seats in the election to tie control of the House at 67-67.According to a tally by The Associated Press, the chamber stood at 65-65 Wednesday afternoon. It would end in a 67-67 tie if the leaders of the last four undeclared races remain ahead. Two of them are so razor-thin that automatic recounts have been triggered unless lawmakers waive them.The last time the House was tied was in 1979, and the history of that legislative session suggests that power-sharing will be contentious.In […]
Election 2024: See results across San Francisco
See below for full election results from across San Francisco, including precinct-level maps and ranked-choice votings results. A total of 44.9 percent of ballots have been counted as of Nov. […] Election 2024: See results across San Francisco Source: missionlocal.org
Kremlin aide says Germany car industry plight shows green transition risks
By Vladimir Soldatkin SOCHI, Russia (Reuters) - Russian industry may suffer the fate of car makers in Germany, which have shed tens of thousands of jobs, if it moves too fast to replace fossil fuels, a Kremlin adviser said on Wednesday. "The Russian Federation supports a gradual transition, a gradual transformation, so as to avoid shock scenarios on the energy markets, industrial markets," Kremlin climate envoy Ruslan Edelgeriyev told a conference in Sochi, southern Russia. "Miscalculated ambitions damaged Germany's auto industry," he said, speaking five days before the next U.N. climate change conference begins in Baku, Azerbaijan. Russia is the world's biggest exporter of natural gas and number two exporter of oil. It is one of the world's top carbon dioxide emitters along with China, the United States and India. Russia joined the Paris climate change pact in 2019, which […]
Related
Danny Sauter, set to win District 3, had area-wide appeal
Danny Sauter leads the District 3 Supervisor race with 56 percent of the votes, leading his closest challenger Sharon Lai by 1,821 votes, according to the latest results.Though another 157,000 votes remain to be counted, ranked-choice voting experts said Sauter is unlikely to lose his commanding lead. For Lai to win, the remaining votes “would have to be very, very different to what we’ve seen so far. They have to be much more pro-Sharon,” said Jason McDaniel, San Francisco State University political science professor with a research focus on ranked-choice voting.“I don’t see that happening,” he added. Note: These results are preliminary. Table created by Kelly Waldron. Data released by the San Francisco Department of Elections on Nov. 6 at 1 a.m. Sauter, who at 36 would be one of the youngest members of the Board of Supervisors, was endorsed by […]
Daniel Lurie leads after strange and terrible election night: Analysis
It’s a shame that San Francisco’s fascinating election results can’t be viewed in isolation from the strange and terrible returns that propelled Donald Trump once more to the presidency. But the luxury of ignoring the bigger picture is something San Francisco no longer gets to do. As of a shade before 1 a.m., every last in-person vote was tabulated — 37,345 of them (20,000 provisional votes are pending). In-person voting is a bit like shaving with a straight-edge razor or knitting your own pot-holders: You could do it if you wanted to, but hardly anybody does. At present, 234,453 votes have been counted; a shade under 45 percent. The Department of Elections expects around 157,000 more votes to trickle in (including those 20,000 provisional ballots). That would result in perhaps a 75 percent turnout; San Francisco voters show up at an average […]
Election 2024: See results across San Francisco
See below for full election results from across San Francisco, including precinct-level maps and ranked-choice votings results. A total of 44.9 percent of ballots have been counted as of Nov. […] Election 2024: See results across San Francisco Source: missionlocal.org
Live updates from San Francisco November races
Follow along for Mission Local’s live updates for Election Day from across San Francisco. For updates in the run-up to the election, click here, and to learn more about the candidates and measures on the ballot, go to our election dashboard. If you like our coverage, consider supporting Mission Local. It’s a heck of an effort, today and every day. Election analysisTuesday, Nov. 5: Today is Election Day in San Francisco. Here’s what to expect.Imagine a political campaign is like a ski ramp, with candidates gaining momentum before soaring off into the unknown. If so, that would render Mark Farrell the Vinko Bogataj of the 2024 San Francisco mayoral campaign. You probably don’t know this name, but you probably do know who this is: He’s the Yugoslavian skier whose horrifying ski-jump-gone-wrong for many years defined “the agony of defeat” in […]
Jury shown video of Nima Momeni’s stabbing motions
In a win for the prosecution, jurors today were shown a video in which alleged killer Nima Momeni made distinct stabbing motions, which prosecutors say match those that killed Cash App founder Bob Lee. The video was shown over objections from Momeni’s defense team. The jury was also shown images of the exact locations of Lee’s stab wounds, during testimony from Assistant Medical Examiner Ellen Moffatt. The video was recorded by San Francisco police Sgt. David Goff, who was tracking Momeni’s movements in the days after the stabbing in April 2023. When he captured Momeni on video, the defendant was talking to Brian Hedley, a private investigator who worked for Momeni’s former defense attorney, Paula Canny. In the video, Hedley and Momeni are standing in the parking lot at Canny’s office and the video shows Momeni making three arm movements — two to […]
A mural defaced, restored and its evolution
This weekend, a sharp resident noticed on Saturday morning that Marta Ayala Minero’s mural on the northeast corner of 24th and Valencia streets had been vandalized. When I contacted Ayala on Saturday, she said she would be out the next day to restore it. And indeed she did just that. Restored by the artist Marta Ayala Minero on Sunday, November 2.2024. Courtesy of the artist. Marta Ayala Minero’s mural on 24th and Valencia Street. Restored on Sunday. Photo by a community contributor. When I mentioned that the mural had been somewhat different earlier, she gave me a lesson on its evolution. First painted in 1992, thanks to a grant from the Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development, Roots and Frequencies Basic to Our Education “had a lady speaking the phrase for “nonviolence” in a few languages.”The mural was based on a dream […]
