Youth advocates and community groups sent a joint letter to the San Francisco Police Commission on Wednesday requesting that a potential new policy on how police interact with juveniles further limit the use of handcuffs. It also asked that officers default to the least restrictive response possible when dealing with youths.
At present, the draft policy gives officers discretion on whether to handcuff youths being taken to non-jail facilities. It allows youths to be handcuffed until a search can be conducted by their preferred gender of officer. Juveniles may also be handcuffed to a stationary object for a maximum of 30 minutes, with room for extensions. There is no other mention of when to use handcuffs.
The policy has long been planned in group meetings that have included police commissioners and other stakeholders, including the nine groups that signed onto today’s letter.
The new version of the policy, which would replace one approved in 2008, takes a more trauma-informed approach than the prior one, but the groups that signed the letter said it does not go far enough.
“We believe that revisions … are long overdue and commend the San Francisco Police Department on its efforts to update this policy,” read the letter, signed by youth groups like Huckleberry Youth Programs, Legal Services for Children, Instituto Familiar de la Raza, and the Public Defender’s Office.
“However, further revisions are needed, as portions of the current proposed version are out of compliance with the law and out of step with best practices in the field.”
The groups’ recommendations note the harms of handcuffing youths.
“The [policy’s] procedures for criminal offenses for youth 12 years or older have improved,” the letter reads, but adds that any new policy “must go further to guide members in pursuing alternatives that are less restrictive than arrest and incarceration.”
At present, the new revisions do include an introductory statement that officers should “strive to take the alternative that is least restrictive to a youth’s freedom of movement,” as long as that is in the youth’s and the community’s best interest.
“Youth, particularly those who have experienced trauma, special needs, or developmental challenges, may have a challenging time exercising self-control, have heightened anxiety, and are less likely to trust unfamiliar adults including law enforcement,” the policy reads in the “purpose” section of the policy. “Misperceptions about youth of color (including perceiving them as older than they are) by media, law enforcement and the general public have historically led to disparate outcomes.”
The policy bars officers from engaging in “unnecessary conversation” or questioning a minor until they have spoken with a lawyer and been advised of their right to have a parent or other adult present.
The change brings the policy into accordance with a city ordinance, passed in 2019, that requires juveniles to consult with a lawyer before they can waive any Miranda rights.
The current juvenile policy, in effect since 2008, only requires that officers inform the juvenile that they may have a parent or lawyer present during an interrogation — but the child must request their presence.
The drafted policy also states that youth 13 or younger cannot be handcuffed or kept in a locked room, and cannot be kept by police for more than six hours. If a child 11 or younger committed a violent crime like murder or rape, they are to be sent to Juvenile Probation Department custody.
If the youth is 14 or older, and presents a “serious security risk” of harming themselves or others, they can be handcuffed, but still should not be kept for more than six hours.
The youth advocate groups recommended several additional requirements such as supervisor approvals and adequate supervision they said are required under state law.
Depending on the nature of their crime, those 12 or older will be transferred to other youth custody groups like the Juvenile Probation Department or the Community Assessment and Referral Center.
Though both the 2008 version and latest draft of the policy both require “reasonable” access to toilets and water, or snacks if the youth hasn’t eaten in four hours, the advocates demanded more in today’s letter.
They want unconditional access to toilets, drinking water, language services, disability services, and menstrual products, and snacks, blankets and clothing as needed.
These changes, the group said, would bring the policy into compliance with state law. These recommendations were already made in a prior letter some of the same advocacy groups wrote in March.
During a mass arrest of juveniles during the Dolores Park Hill Bomb event last year, children reported being detained in the street and not given extra clothing or permitted to urinate for hours. Some allegedly urinated on themselves.
Four of those youths filed a lawsuit against the city in December, and said in it that they used a bucket dropped down to the street by a concerned neighbor.
Commissioner Kevin Benedicto, who said he has been working on the draft with Commissioner Jesús Yáñez, said a final draft should be before the commission in November.
You can read the letter and draft policy here.
About the author
Fresh Cranberry Sauce With Orange & Cinnamon
Better Living uses affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them, we may receive a small commission (for which we are deeply grateful) at no cost to you. Once you try this homemade, fresh cranberry sauce with orange & cinnamon, you’ll be upset that you’ve gone so many Thanksgivings without it. Ordinary store-bought cans of “cranberry sauce” simply pale in comparison. The tartness of the berries is perfectly balanced by the sweetness of the sugar and elevated with a hint of orange and cinnamon. It’s not too sweet though. If you like the texture and bite of whole berries in your sauce, take it off the heat as soon as all the berries have popped. For a smoother cranberry sauce, continue cooking it a bit longer than suggested. This is sure to be a Thanksgiving table staple for […]
Accused Nima Momeni grows combative
In a contentious second day on the witness stand in his own murder trial, Nima Momeni struggled — or refused — to provide much detail about the April 2023 stabbing death of Cash App founder Bob Lee, or to explain his behavior in the days after the killing. Instead, Momeni was argumentative under cross-examination by prosecutor Omid Talai, who attempted to cast doubt on Momeni’s claim that he acted in self-defense. On Wednesday, Momeni offered jurors his narrative of what happened in the early morning hours of April 4, 2023, when Lee ended up bleeding out in the street with three stab wounds. Momeni testified that Lee had pulled a knife on him after he cracked a “bad joke” about spending more time with his family instead of strip clubs. Lee’s reaction forced Momeni to defend himself. Momeni said that he had no idea […]
More Russians denounce each other over Ukraine, in echo of Soviet era
By Mark TrevelyanLONDON (Reuters) - On the last day of January, a woman took her son to see paediatrician Nadezhda Buyanova at Polyclinic No. 140 in northwest Moscow. The boy, aged seven, had a problem with one of his eyes.The conversation that the boy's mother alleged took place during an 18-minute encounter at the clinic would change both women's lives and land the 68-year-old doctor in prison.The case hinged on a denunciation - part of a rising trend of Russians informing on fellow citizens for their views on the war in Ukraine and other alleged political crimes. Critics say the wave of denunciations is helping President Vladimir Putin's government crack down on dissent.In a video recorded as she was walking away from the clinic, the mother, Anastasia Akinshina, said she had told the doctor the boy was traumatised because his […]
Chyanne Chen leading in D11, where most provisional ballots have been counted
The San Francisco Department of Elections just released the results of another 6,106 ballots. The total of processed ballots is now 396,543 — 75.93 percent of the electorate.Perhaps 15,800 ballots remain. Of these, 14,400 are provisional ballots cast throughout the city and at City Hall on Election Day. Scrutinizing provisional ballots requires additional time, and not all may be accepted. Let’s dive right into the only two remaining contested races: District 11 supervisor, and the fourth and last open spot on the Board of Education:In District 11, Chyanne Chen is still leading with 11,931 votes to Michael Lai’s 11,727 — just a 204-vote difference. Lai gained one vote compared to yesterday.“Most of the provisional ballots for D11 are now reviewed and processed and those votes are included in the preliminary results reports,” said Elections Director John Arntz. “The remaining provisional ballots are […]
North Korea leader Kim orders mass production of suicide drones, KCNA says
SEOUL (Reuters) -North Korean leader Kim Jong Un guided a test of suicide drones and ordered a mass production of the aerial weapon, saying the introduction of such drones around the world requires an urgent update of military theory, state media said on Friday.Kim had previously supervised the test of suicide drones, earlier in the year amid a rapidly developing military cooperation with Russia, raising questions as to whether he was receiving technical help from Moscow to develop them.Also known as loitering munitions, such weapons have been widely used in the war in Ukraine as well as in the Middle East."(Kim) underscored the need to build a serial production system as early as possible and go into full-scale mass production," state news agency KCNA said.Kim said the competition for using drones for military purposes is accelerating around the world, with […]
Accused Nima Momeni says ‘bad joke’ led to stabbing
Nearly a month into his trial for allegedly killing Cash App founder Bob Lee, Nima Momeni took the witness stand for the first time to describe the stabbing, which he said began after Lee attacked him over a “bad joke.” Jurors today got to hear Momeni, who has been sitting quietly in the courtroom through weeks of testimony, speak about what led him to stab Lee three times in the early morning hours of April 4, 2023. Momeni has been accused of murder, but his attorneys have claimed self-defense.Momeni wore a navy blue suit, spoke with a light Iranian accent, and appeared nervous: He repeatedly cut off attorneys asking him questions and refilled his cup of water several times, prompting Judge Alexandra Gordon to at one point give Momeni a framed “Inhale, Exhale” mini-poster from her bench.Momeni said today that Lee […]
Related
Accused Nima Momeni grows combative
In a contentious second day on the witness stand in his own murder trial, Nima Momeni struggled — or refused — to provide much detail about the April 2023 stabbing death of Cash App founder Bob Lee, or to explain his behavior in the days after the killing. Instead, Momeni was argumentative under cross-examination by prosecutor Omid Talai, who attempted to cast doubt on Momeni’s claim that he acted in self-defense. On Wednesday, Momeni offered jurors his narrative of what happened in the early morning hours of April 4, 2023, when Lee ended up bleeding out in the street with three stab wounds. Momeni testified that Lee had pulled a knife on him after he cracked a “bad joke” about spending more time with his family instead of strip clubs. Lee’s reaction forced Momeni to defend himself. Momeni said that he had no idea […]
Chyanne Chen leading in D11, where most provisional ballots have been counted
The San Francisco Department of Elections just released the results of another 6,106 ballots. The total of processed ballots is now 396,543 — 75.93 percent of the electorate.Perhaps 15,800 ballots remain. Of these, 14,400 are provisional ballots cast throughout the city and at City Hall on Election Day. Scrutinizing provisional ballots requires additional time, and not all may be accepted. Let’s dive right into the only two remaining contested races: District 11 supervisor, and the fourth and last open spot on the Board of Education:In District 11, Chyanne Chen is still leading with 11,931 votes to Michael Lai’s 11,727 — just a 204-vote difference. Lai gained one vote compared to yesterday.“Most of the provisional ballots for D11 are now reviewed and processed and those votes are included in the preliminary results reports,” said Elections Director John Arntz. “The remaining provisional ballots are […]
Accused Nima Momeni says ‘bad joke’ led to stabbing
Nearly a month into his trial for allegedly killing Cash App founder Bob Lee, Nima Momeni took the witness stand for the first time to describe the stabbing, which he said began after Lee attacked him over a “bad joke.” Jurors today got to hear Momeni, who has been sitting quietly in the courtroom through weeks of testimony, speak about what led him to stab Lee three times in the early morning hours of April 4, 2023. Momeni has been accused of murder, but his attorneys have claimed self-defense.Momeni wore a navy blue suit, spoke with a light Iranian accent, and appeared nervous: He repeatedly cut off attorneys asking him questions and refilled his cup of water several times, prompting Judge Alexandra Gordon to at one point give Momeni a framed “Inhale, Exhale” mini-poster from her bench.Momeni said today that Lee […]
Few new votes, but Chyanne Chen keeps lead in District 11
The San Francisco Department of Elections just dropped the results of another 1,679 ballots, bringing the total of processed ballots to 390,437 — 74.76 percent of the electorate.Even though the count has been going slow so far this week, John Arntz, the director of the Department of Elections told Mission Local on Monday that they will “have most of the remaining ballot cards processed and reported this week.” San Francisco is seeing a record-low turnout this year with the total tracking to be about 77.8 percent. The average San Francisco turnout in a presidential year, going back 108 years, is 77 percent. All eyes are now on the only two remaining contested races: District 11 supervisor, and the fourth and last seat on the Board of Education:In District 11, Chyanne Chen kept up with her lead with 11,863 votes to her moderate […]
SF immigration advocates prepare for Trump administration
San Francisco’s status as a sanctuary city places it in the bullseye for an attack from an emboldened Donald Trump administration. This time, however, lawyers and community advocates have seen the playbook, and have already begun steeling themselves. “This is the second time around … and he’s got more ideas, apparently,” said Bill Hing, the founding director of the University of San Francisco’s Immigration and Deportation Defense Clinic. “So we have got to prepare for the worst.”Changes to the immigration systemHing predicts immigration advocates will face both ideological and procedural challenges. Take domestic violence cases, for example. People escaping domestic violence currently make up the majority of cases successfully handled by Hing’s clinic. These cases will soon become more difficult to win, as Hing expects the federal attorney general appointed by Trump will hold a narrower definition of what justifies political asylum that […]
Chyanne Chen’s slim lead grows — barely
The San Francisco Department of Elections moments ago released the results of an additional 6,466 ballots. That brings the grand total of processed ballots to 388,758 — 74.44 percent of the electorate.There are now very few ballots remaining — largely provisional ballots cast at citywide polling places and at City Hall. Today is also the last day for any mail ballot postmarked on Election Day or earlier to reach City Hall and be counted. All told, 18,200 additional ballots remain uncounted, including 14,500 provisional ones. Verifying provisional ballots requires additional scrutiny — and, naturally, additional time.Turnout is tracking to be about 77.8 percent, maximum. The average San Francisco turnout in a presidential year, going back 108 years, is 77 percent. Around 43,000 fewer San Franciscans will have cast a ballot in 2024 than they did four years ago. There are only two remaining contested […]
