On June 29, Mayor London Breed texted Carla Short, the director of San Francisco Public Works, asking her to send out a crew to pick up trash in the Tenderloin.
“I’m at Azalina’s. Are you around? You should stop by,” read the text from Breed, sent at 5:54 p.m. while the mayor was at a Malaysian restaurant near Ellis and Leavenworth streets. “Can you send someone to clean up across the street please. It [sic] a pile of trash on the south west corner.”
Short said she was at a Giants game but promised to “send someone now.”
“That would be great,” Breed wrote in response. “I want her to succeed but the tents and trash are a problem,” she added, seemingly referencing a homeless woman on the corner. “We will deal with the tents. Thank you and enjoy the game.”
That simple text exchange, which was deleted by Breed from her personal phone but recovered from Short’s device, has revealed a practice within the mayor’s office of routinely deleting text messages and other day-to-day communiques — a practice public records experts say violates California law.
“If Mayor Breed’s texts were about government business and less than two years old, it would be illegal for her to delete them,” said Susan Seager, a First Amendment expert and law professor at UC Irvine who runs the university’s Press Freedom and Transparency initiative. “State law says that public records must be retained for two years. San Francisco is not allowed to nullify state law with its own policies and rules.”
Nevertheless, it has been the policy of San Francisco since 2014 to allow the mayor to delete texts. Half a dozen public records experts said that was a problem, and that the mayor was opening the city up to litigation by deleting texts dealing with official business.
But the mayor’s office sees things differently — and without a lawsuit forcing the matter, it is unclear the practice will change.
Mayor’s texts are ‘non-records’
The mayor’s practice of deleting text messages came to light last month during an Aug. 20 hearing of the Sunshine Ordinance Task Force, the local body responsible for overseeing San Francisco’s public records law.
The task force was considering a complaint filed against the mayor’s office accusing it of failing to respond to a public records request in a timely manner, and then failing to turn over any records at all.
On June 29, a frequent filer of public records requests named Hazel Williams asked for the latest message from Breed on a variety of platforms, like SMS, Signal, and WhatsApp. The mayor, like other city officials, uses her personal phone to conduct city business and speak to staff.
The mayor’s office, after a lengthy delay, wrote on Aug. 8 that it had nothing responsive to the request from Williams. In other words, the mayor had no text messages whatsoever dealing with official city business.
Williams’ requests to other city departments, however, revealed communication between Breed and Public Works, when Public Works responded with the text exchange between its director and Breed.
“I really want to drive this point home: I have text messages sent from the mayor on the day that I asked the mayor’s office for her latest text message,” said Williams. “And yet the mayor’s office says they have no records.”
Hank Heckel, the mayor’s legal compliance officer, wrote in a statement that “Unless such texts have independent legal significance, the individual officials and staff in the Mayor’s Office generally determine whether or not to continue to store individual texts on their phones.”
Breed’s texts, Heckel said at the Aug. 20 hearing, are “typically treated as non-records … in the parlance of record retention policies.”
2014 policy may have always violated California law
Those policies date back to 2014 and Mayor Ed Lee. Since then, San Francisco mayors have abided by local public records retention guidelines that allow for the routine destruction of day-to-day communications that are not defined as “records” under the city’s administrative code.
San Francisco Administrative Code §8 defines records as “paper, book, photograph, film, sound recording, map, drawing or other document … made or received by the department in connection with the transaction of public business.”
Although the code does not specifically include text messages, emails, voicemails, or other routine communications, the mayor’s office has since 2014 interpreted “records” to exclude such communiques, meaning they “may be destroyed when no longer needed,” according to the retention policy.
Five of the six experts who spoke to Mission Local, however, disagreed with this interpretation, saying a practice of deleting texts before two years violates California state law — and that the 2014 policy has likely always violated state law. San Francisco Administrative Code §8.3 notes that “Nothing in this Section shall be deemed to apply to or authorize the destruction of any records that are required to be retained by local, State or federal law.”
“The mayor’s compliance officer is wrong,” said Karl Olson, a 35-year public records attorney. Olson successfully argued a 2017 case in front of the California Supreme Court called City of San Jose v. Superior Court, in which the court ruled that public officials’ messages on personal devices are still public records.
Olson pointed to that City of San Jose decision, in which he represented a resident seeking to obtain texts from a city council member’s private phone. He also noted that California Government Code §34090 separately requires that public records be maintained for a period of at least two years.
“The definition of a public record is anything except the shopping list from home,” he said, pointing to the two-year retention requirement for records. “When you’re texting about public business, then that’s gonna be a public record.”
The San Francisco city attorney’s office declined to comment on the matter.
“San Francisco seems to claim that texts/emails are simply not public records (unless extra, significant circumstances apply), and thus not disclosable,” wrote Brian Hofer, the founder of the Oakland nonprofit Secure Justice and the inaugural chair of Oakland’s privacy commission. “That’s a silly position to take.”
For his part, Heckel also noted that the mayor’s retention policy is similar to that of the Board of Supervisors and other city departments. It is unclear whether other elected officials, like supervisors, also have a practice of routinely deleting messages.
It’s also unclear to what extent Mayor Lee and other mayors deleted their text messages. Williams said she believes Breed’s practice of deleting texts goes back to 2020, when a trove of text messages publicized by Williams showed Breed personally directed staff, including the police chief, to “clear,” “clean,” and “fix” homeless encampments around the city. “After that,” Williams said, “I was unable to get anything from the mayor’s office.”
David Loy, an attorney and the legal director of the First Amendment Coalition, sees more wiggle room for the mayor and San Francisco. He said that while the deletion is a problem and opens the city up to litigation, the definition of “records” under California law is nebulous and has never been adequately defined by state courts.
There is a “hodgepodge of different laws and local rules” that govern retention of records in California, Loy said. “To my knowledge, no court has held that the law requires cities to retain every kind of record under the [California Public Records Act],” he said. “There is some play at the joints here about what the record retention laws are and the obligations of an agency.”
Still, the experts were unanimous that the practice of deleting messages hampers government transparency and keeps the public in the dark about official conduct.
“When you’re a public official — someone dedicated to working and performing your duties in the name of the people — that comes with an obligation to have a light shined upon your activities,” said Gunita Singh, a staff attorney at the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press. “There’s no excuse for shielding [records] from the public by way of loose compliance with records retention schedules. The mayor’s office should do better.”
About the author
Gordon Ramsay’s Secret Ingredient For Steak Is One We Wish We’d Known Before
Chefs often consider tenderloin or filet mignon to be overrated cuts of steak, but Gordon Ramsay disagrees. The filet, or filet mignon, is one of his "favorite cuts of all time" because it is "packed with flavor" (per YouTube). Due to its leanness, it's a cut that can easily overcook and become dry, which is why it's one of the worst cuts of steak to grill. But Ramsay uses an unexpected ingredient to keep it juicy: chicken stock.First, the chef sears both sides of his meat in a skillet -- laying the meat away from you rather than towards you is Ramsay's tip for not burning yourself when making steak. Then he adds garlic, rosemary, thyme, and a bay leaf before pouring in the stock. Adding the extra liquid means more moist meat since some of it is absorbed by the […]
District 5 candidates on how they will speed up housing
Here’s the latest in our “Meet the Candidates” series for District 5, in which we ask each candidate to answer one question per week leading up to the election. Four candidates are challenging incumbent Supervisor Dean Preston to represent District 5, which spans from the east end of Golden Gate Park through Haight-Ashbury, Japantown and the Western Addition, the Lower Haight and Hayes Valley, and most of the Tenderloin.San Francisco has a new mandate from the state of California to build 82,000 new homes by 2031, with more than half of those to be affordable to low- and moderate-income households. We’re not on track to meet this goal, and one of the big arguments in San Francisco’s housing debate — particularly as campaigning heats up in District 5 — has been over who is to blame for our slow housing […]
Hong Kong sees biggest uptick in cryptocurrency activity in East Asia, new report finds
Hong Kong has seen the biggest uptick in cryptocurrency activity in East Asia amid the city's efforts to become a virtual-asset hub, according to new research, while mainland Chinese use digital currencies to preserve wealth in spite of the government's draconian ban.The city rose to 30th place, up from the No 47 spot last year, in this year's Global Cryptocurrency Adoption Index rankings published on Wednesday by research firm Chainalysis. It said Hong Kong saw an 85.6 per cent year-on-year surge in cryptocurrency transaction value, the largest growth seen in East Asia.Hong Kong regulators' acceptance of cryptocurrencies and "decisiveness" in laying down a regulatory framework helped build up institutional adoption, according to Chainalysis. Its index measures activities across several types of cryptocurrency services, including centralised exchanges and decentralised protocols.Do you have questions about the biggest topics and trends from around […]
SFUSD’s delay in announcing public school closures is a disgrace
Many years ago, the comedian George Wallace ridiculed the notion of the U.S. military developing a faster bomber. Was this, he asked, a problem? Have the many people the United States has bombed been waiting outside and asking “When’s that bomber going to get here?” In related news, the San Francisco Unified School District was, tomorrow, supposed to release its preliminary list of schools that will be closed and/or merged — the moment of truth in a nine-month ordeal. Mission Local has learned that, on Friday, the district realized it would have to delay this announcement. A planned Monday statement from superintendent Matt Wayne instead dropped over the weekend when the news of the delay got out and questions were being asked. And now public school parents are more irate, not less. When’s that bomber going to get here? No need to mince words: […]
Before Implosion, “Titan ”Pilot and CEO Had Panicked Meltdown When He Crashed Into a Shipwreck: Ex-Employee
"It was unprofessional behavior of him, he started to panic," David Lochridge testified of Stockton RushYears before he piloted the Titan submersible more than 2 miles beneath the surface of the Northern Atlantic Ocean on a doomed voyage to see the wreckage of the Titanic, Stockton Rush took another small group of passengers to see another famed ship beneath the waves — but fell into “panic” due to a lack of experience, a former employee claims.David Lochridge, who worked as operations director at OceanGate, which Rush co-founded and ran as CEO, testified on Tuesday, Sept. 17, at an ongoing U.S. Coast Guard hearing about the implosion of Titan while on its way to the Titanic last summer, killing all five people aboard, including Rush.Lochridge did not mince words about his views on Rush or OceanGate.“The whole idea behind the company […]
Vea cómo se postulan: Los demócratas de SF acusan a Mark Farrell de utilizar indebidamente el logotipo de apoyo del partido
Read in EnglishMission Local está publicando artículos de campaña para cada una/uno de los principales contendientes en la carrera por la alcaldía, alternando entre los candidatos semanalmente hasta noviembre. Esta semana: Mark Farrell. Lea los artículos anteriores aquí.El Partido Demócrata de San Francisco ha acusado al candidato a la alcaldía, Mark Farrell, de utilizar indebidamente su logotipo en un folleto sobre la Propuesta D enviado a los votantes la semana pasada. El correo en cuestión, de 20 por 30 centímetros, muestra de forma destacada una foto de Farrell y una cita de su apoyo a la Propuesta D, la medida para limitar las comisiones municipales, junto al logotipo del SF Dems en un círculo azul oscuro, muy similar al sello de apoyo del partido.Aunque el partido ha respaldado la Proposición D, no ha respaldado a Farrell – ese honor fue para […]
Related
District 5 candidates on how they will speed up housing
Here’s the latest in our “Meet the Candidates” series for District 5, in which we ask each candidate to answer one question per week leading up to the election. Four candidates are challenging incumbent Supervisor Dean Preston to represent District 5, which spans from the east end of Golden Gate Park through Haight-Ashbury, Japantown and the Western Addition, the Lower Haight and Hayes Valley, and most of the Tenderloin.San Francisco has a new mandate from the state of California to build 82,000 new homes by 2031, with more than half of those to be affordable to low- and moderate-income households. We’re not on track to meet this goal, and one of the big arguments in San Francisco’s housing debate — particularly as campaigning heats up in District 5 — has been over who is to blame for our slow housing […]
SFUSD’s delay in announcing public school closures is a disgrace
Many years ago, the comedian George Wallace ridiculed the notion of the U.S. military developing a faster bomber. Was this, he asked, a problem? Have the many people the United States has bombed been waiting outside and asking “When’s that bomber going to get here?” In related news, the San Francisco Unified School District was, tomorrow, supposed to release its preliminary list of schools that will be closed and/or merged — the moment of truth in a nine-month ordeal. Mission Local has learned that, on Friday, the district realized it would have to delay this announcement. A planned Monday statement from superintendent Matt Wayne instead dropped over the weekend when the news of the delay got out and questions were being asked. And now public school parents are more irate, not less. When’s that bomber going to get here? No need to mince words: […]
Vea cómo se postulan: Los demócratas de SF acusan a Mark Farrell de utilizar indebidamente el logotipo de apoyo del partido
Read in EnglishMission Local está publicando artículos de campaña para cada una/uno de los principales contendientes en la carrera por la alcaldía, alternando entre los candidatos semanalmente hasta noviembre. Esta semana: Mark Farrell. Lea los artículos anteriores aquí.El Partido Demócrata de San Francisco ha acusado al candidato a la alcaldía, Mark Farrell, de utilizar indebidamente su logotipo en un folleto sobre la Propuesta D enviado a los votantes la semana pasada. El correo en cuestión, de 20 por 30 centímetros, muestra de forma destacada una foto de Farrell y una cita de su apoyo a la Propuesta D, la medida para limitar las comisiones municipales, junto al logotipo del SF Dems en un círculo azul oscuro, muy similar al sello de apoyo del partido.Aunque el partido ha respaldado la Proposición D, no ha respaldado a Farrell – ese honor fue para […]
Wells Fargo sign blows loose; firefighters on scene
Sign up below to get Mission Local’s free newsletter, a daily digest of news you won’t find elsewhere. The corner of Mission and 22nd has been sealed off and firefighters have ascended a ladder to remove a Wells Fargo sign overlooking the intersection, which came loose during a gusty day. Earlier in the evening, pedestrians were asked to avoid the vicinity in the event the large red-and-yellow bank sign fell. Building representatives were also on scene, and the fire department said it was opening to securing or removing the sign. They chose the latter, with the property owner’s permission. “This is an isolated hazard and we ask that you avoid the area,” the fire department added in a statement, advising travelers to plan alternative routes. Want the latest on the Mission and San Francisco? Sign up for our free daily […]
United Dumplings: A Bernal Heights delight
The original United Dumplings has been on Cortland in Bernal since late 2020, but my first time trying their food was just last year at their Oakland location. Women-owned, United Dumplings offers a mix of tradition and innovation, and it all tastes authentically great. I was blown away by the quality of the dumplings and the variety of offerings — of not just dumplings but the myriad noodles, rice, veggie, and tofu options. I was overjoyed to learn (very belatedly) that we had one so close to the Mission. The original is a bit more casual and spare than its East Bay cousin, but the menus seem to be identical. (There’s also another outpost in the Marina.)Pea shoots I tried in Oakland were a favorite, so I had to have them here.Pea ShootsThey were so abundantly garlicky, and so lusciously creamy, they almost seemed […]
Controller assumes de facto control of Human Rights Commission
In a Friday afternoon letter to San Francisco officials, city controller Greg Wagner announced his office would essentially assume control of the scandal-plagued Human Rights Commission, with his “accounting staff immediately to oversee accounting operations at HRC, including approvals of payments and other financial transactions.”The Human Rights Commission’s director, Sheryl Davis, resigned at Mayor London Breed’s behest yesterday and hired a defense attorney after a slew of news articles alleging cavalier or even potentially illegal spending.The San Francisco Chronicle on Thursday revealed that Davis spent some $10,000 renting a home for city interns on Martha’s Vineyard, allegedly splitting the invoice to evade city reporting requirements for purchases of $10,000 or more. On the same day, the San Francisco Standard noted that Davis had directed some $1.5 million in funding to the nonprofit Collective Impact, which is overseen by James Spignola. […]
Be the first to leave a comment