Welcome back to the “Meet the Candidates” series for the school board, where we ask each candidate one question every two weeks. They must answer the question in 100 words or fewer. We will link to longer answers.
Eleven candidates are vying for four seats on the city’s seven-person school board. The election will take place on Nov. 5. Non-citizen parents of children living in the city are permitted to vote in school board elections, and can find information on doing so here.
On Aug. 23, then-President of the San Francisco Unified School District school board Lainie Motamedi resigned, more than two years after being appointed by Mayor London Breed, citing “personal and health reasons.” That same day, Mayor Breed swore in Phil Kim to serve on the board, and Vice President Matt Alexander became President.
Kim’s extensive background in charter education — including a more than decade-long stint as a teacher, then senior director of STEM education at KIPP charter schools — has raised concerns among the teachers union and other groups opposed to charters, and opened up questions about how public school districts should relate to charter schools.
This week, we asked the candidates:
How successful, in your view, have charter schools been when it comes to serving San Francisco students, and do you support their expansion?
Most of the candidates do not currently support expanding charter schools in San Francisco, and say the district needs to address ongoing budget problems, a decline in enrollment and school closures. But some candidates say select charter schools have succeeded in narrowing equity gaps, and can be models for how to improve public education in the city.
Madeline Krantz
- Job: Dual enrollment student at CCSF and SJSU
- Age: 19
- Residency: Inner Sunset
- Educational background: Synergy School for K-8, Abraham Lincoln High School, experience working as teacher’s aide in synagogue and currently working toward education degree
- SFUSD experience: Worked with SFUSD students as part of Teacher Academy at Lincoln
- Languages: English
Several charter schools in San Francisco have been successful, and we should see what we can learn from them that could help all of SFUSD. But especially in years when we know we’re facing big budget cuts and even school closures, I don’t think we should expand charter schools if that means taking away funding from public schools that are struggling. We need to make sure we are taking care of all our students first.
Laurance Lee
- Job: Small business owner, L3 Construction LLC
- Age: 54
- Residency: Noe Valley
- Educational background: Went to SFUSD K-12, bachelor’s degree in chemistry and history of science from Harvard University, graduate work at Stanford University
- SFUSD experience: SFUSD Citizens’ Bond Oversight Committee, extended family who are SFUSD student and educators
- Languages: English
Charter schools have been good for about 7,000 students and, at the same time, they have actually been losing students faster than our public schools over the past few years. I don’t support charter school expansion.
As a K-12 SFUSD graduate, my focus as a School Board candidate has been on helping our 49,000 non-charter students. I have been working to restore faith in our bond facilities spending by restarting the Citizens Bond Oversight Committee* [a group that reviews how the district’s bond funds are spent] and working with the new auditors. I have been advocating for low-cost means to address chronic absenteeism, literacy outcomes, and improving student safety. We … read more here
Endorsed by: SF Guardians, State Treasurer Fiona Ma, former School Board President Emily Murase … read more here
Supryia Ray
- Job: Attorney and writer
- Age: 51
- Residency: Sunset
- Educational background: Bachelor’s degree in political science and French from University of Miami, summa cum laude; juris doctor degree from Harvard Law School, magna cum laude
- SFUSD experience: Parent of two SFUSD students; Jefferson Elementary parent-teacher association leadership; parent advocate on issues such as outdoor learning and school safety
- Languages: French, some Spanish
Like all schools, the quality and success of charter schools vary considerably. Some of SFUSD’s unique charters operate in admirable ways, offering families alternatives they may need. But every school funded by public funds should be subject to appropriate oversight and accountability. If elected, I will insist on that.
SFUSD is in a fiscal crisis and is reducing its overall number of schools. We must make the transitions as smooth as possible for affected families and students. For this reason, I do not currently support expanding the number of charter or regular public schools (apart from Mission Bay).
Endorsed by: SF Democratic Party, SF Guardians, SF Parent Action, GrowSF … read more here
Matt Alexander
- Job: Community organizer at Faith in Action Bay Area, incumbent board member
- Age: 54
- Residency: Outer Sunset
- Educational background: Master’s degree in education
- SFUSD experience: Teacher and principal; current school board vice president
- Languages: English, Spanish
I’m opposed to new charter schools in San Francisco. The original intent of charter school laws when they were passed 35 years ago was to provide a space for grassroots innovation, led by teachers, which would then benefit the public school system. Many of the charters in San Francisco do fit this description. Educators at some San Francisco charters have unionized. But charter laws generally have been co-opted by corporate entities intent on undermining public education. Especially when San Francisco is facing a declining population of children, and SFUSD’s enrollment is declining, we don’t need any new charters.
Endorsed by: UESF, Harvey Milk LGBTQ Democratic Club
Min Chang
- Job: CEO at healthcare organization Homebridge
- Age: 58
- Residency: San Francisco
- Educational background: Ph.D. in international affairs and master’s degree in international public policy from Johns Hopkins University; master’s degree in management from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Sloan; bachelor’s degrees from the University of Pennsylvania
- SFUSD experience: Doing outreach in SFUSD and attending school board meetings.
- Languages: English, Chinese, French
My focus is on SFUSD. We should raise performance of schools/curriculum by bringing back the basics like math, science, history, civics, the arts; expand accelerated/gifted programs and keep language immersion. We should support educators, especially now given the tremendous demands placed on them with pending school closures, shortage of teachers, and teachers pulling double-duty. We should work hard to keep schools open, not close them, and provide a secure environment for kids to learn without fear of bullying and harassment. Until improvements are made, parents need choices and charter schools are options, but my focus is on improving … read more here
Endorsed by: The San Francisco Republican Party, San Francisco Young Republicans, The Republican Club of San Francisco, San Francisco Briones Society … read more here
Virginia Cheung
- Job: SFUSD parent, co-founder and vice president of Give a Beat Foundation (volunteer work) and previously director of advancement at Wu Yee Children’s Services
- Age: 41
- Residency: District 11
- Educational background: Bachelor’s degree in social ecology (first in family to graduate college).
- SFUSD experience: Parent of Alice Fong Yu student; Wah Mei BASE! ExCEL program Parent Advisory Board
- Languages: Basic Cantonese and Mandarin, conversational French
While charter schools can meet specific community needs, expanding them should not be a district-wide strategy. Charter schools divert funding from public education, cost more to maintain, and can isolate communities. Rather than expanding charter schools, we must invest in SFUSD’s public schools, which are accountable to voters and serve all children, especially the most vulnerable.
Public schools foster equity and community, ensuring every child has access to a quality education. Strengthening public schools supports teachers, improves learning environments, and uses taxpayer dollars more effectively. Our public schools must remain a public good for all students to ensure a stronger, … read more here
Endorsed by: Harvey Milk LGBTQ Democratic Club, Mayor London Breed, Supervisor Rafael Mandelman, School Board Commissioner Jenny Lam … read more here
Lefteris Eleftheriou
- Job: Regional sales manager, Sanyo Denki
- Age: 56
- Residency: District 7
- Educational background: Bachelor’s degree in engineering, master’s degree in education
- SFUSD experience: No direct experience, but previously ran an art school in Belmont.
- Languages: English, Japanese, Greek
My goal is to improve the quality of education provided by the SFUSD. We live in a free market economy and so if the SFUSD is providing an inferior product or service, then the competition will identify this as a business opportunity and step in. That is why we are seeing a rise in alternative education models, such as private schools, charter schools, homeschooling, etc. There is nothing inherently wrong with this; it’s just how competition in a free market works. Having said that, as a member of the BOE, and having worked with some of the world’s best performing … read more here
Parag Gupta
- Job: Chief program officer at Mercy Housing
- Age: 46
- Residency: San Francisco
- Educational background: Bachelor’s degree with honors from the University of Chicago; master’s degree in Public Policy from Harvard University
- SFUSD experience: Parent of recent CIS De Avila grad; School Site Council chair; 8th grade algebra focus group; drafting SFUSD policy priorities for SF Democrats as SF DCCC member; developing financial strategy for Stupski Foundation programs to help students, including SFUSD students, complete postsecondary education
- Languages: Basic Spanish, basic French, conversational Hindi
Research suggests charter school expansion adversely impacts the financial stability of school districts. Given the particularly precarious financial situation of SFUSD, I do not currently support the expansion of charter schools.
As for success, each charter school’s performance must be evaluated individually as schools are governed differently and serve different students. Looking at ’21-’22 outcomes, KIPP and Mission Prep, who primarily serve Black and Brown students from low-income families, have performed well in Math and English Language Arts scores compared to peer SFUSD schools. We should understand this success and what we may be able to replicate within our public … read more here
Endorsed by: SF Democratic Party, Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi, Senator Scott Wiener, UESF … read more here
Ann Hsu
- Job: Head of School at Bertrand D Hsu American & Chinese Bicultural Academy
- Age: 57
- Residency: Richmond District
- Educational background: Bachelor’s degree in electrical engineering from Pennsylvania State University, master’s degree in electrical engineering and master’s in business from University of California, Berkeley
- SFUSD experience: Two sons in SFUSD; SFUSD Citizens’ Bond Oversight Committee chair; Galileo High School PTSA president; active in recall efforts; appointed by Mayor Breed to school board in 2022 and served until early 2023
- Languages: English; Chinese, Mandarin
SFUSD has 12 charter schools as of June 2024; all the charter schools are located in the city center and eastside.
The composition of charter schools is 55% Latino, 15% Black and only 5% Asians. Evidence from standardized test scores and AP participation rates, while not conclusive, indicate that Black and Latino students do much better in some charter schools than in SFUSD.
As a public school district, our focus should be on student success, and therefore, I support any school that educates students well and gives families options for their children’s education.
Jaime Huling
- Job: Deputy city attorney, formerly in San Francisco and now in Oakland
- Age: 42
- Residency: Glen Park; previously Hayes Valley and 13 years in the Mission
- Educational background: Juris doctor degree from Stanford Law School with distinction; bachelor’s in history from Northwestern University with honors, minor in gender studies
- SFUSD experience: Parent of SFUSD Spanish immersion school student; worked with Mission-based nonprofit ScholarMatch to help first-gen, low-income students of color attend college, including SFUSD students
- Languages: English, some Spanish and French
The school district is on the verge of bankruptcy and takeover by the state due to its budget crisis, worsened by declining enrollment. I don’t support the expansion of charter schools, which would take students and funding away from the district and lead to the closing of more SFUSD schools.
Still, SFUSD can learn from what’s worked in San Francisco charter schools to improve student achievement. For example, Mission Preparatory School’s success in closing the racial achievement gap in math shows the effectiveness of increased instructional minutes.
Endorsed by: SF Democratic Party, UESF, SF Parent Action, GrowSF … read more here
John Jersin
- Job: Co-founder of education nonprofit Jersin Foundation, previously a LinkedIn executive
- Age: 40
- Residency: Noe Valley
- Educational background: California public schools from kindergarten through college; bachelor’s degree in computer science from the University of California, San Diego, master’s degree in computer science from Stanford University
- SFUSD experience: Brother-in-law of SFUSD teacher; SFUSD Citizens’ Bond Oversight Committee; parent of two young children who will attend SFUSD schools
- Languages: English, learning Mandarin
There are cases where charter schools can perform well, especially when focused on under-resourced communities which should be a key focus. However, the danger of a growing number of charter schools is a slow replacement of the entire public system with a privatized system. This has happened and led to disaster elsewhere, and absolutely must not be allowed to happen here. Especially in light of school closures happening right now, I do not support increasing the number of charter schools in San Francisco.
Endorsed by: SF Democratic Party, UESF, GrowSF, TogetherSF Action … read more here
Candidates are ordered alphabetically but rotated every question. Answers may be lightly edited for formatting, spelling and grammar. If you have questions for the candidates, please let us know at anne@missionlocal.com.
Read the rest of the school board questions here, and the entire “Meet the Candidates” series here.
You can register to vote via the sf.gov website. Illustrations for the series by Neil Ballard.
About the author
Waymo rolls toward San Francisco Airport — showdown brewing
On Friday morning, a driverless Waymo vehicle, for reasons unknown, rolled into a patch of wet cement on the grounds of Laguna Honda Hospital — and sank in. It was, for onlookers, a source of much mirth and cellphone picture-taking. A witness tells your humble narrator that the wet cement ought to have been better demarcated with barricades — but, also, that a human driver would never, ever have made this mistake. Two weeks prior, an official with San Francisco International Airport wrote to the Planning Department. “The City and County of San Francisco, by and through the San Francisco Airport Commission proposes to approve a permit allowing autonomous vehicle companies to map the roads at San Francisco International Airport, ” it read.“Under the Proposed Project, autonomous vehicle companies would be allowed to deploy up to two autonomous vehicles operated by human drivers to […]
Switzerland adopts more EU sanctions on Russia and Belarus
ZURICH (Reuters) - Switzerland adopted the latest EU sanctions package on Russia and Belarus, the government said on Monday. The move came one week after the European Union targeted Moscow's vessels and Chinese entities found to have traded with the Russian military.The Swiss government listed 54 persons and 30 companies and organisations, freezing their assets as of Dec. 24, and banned 52 ships from providing services."These are mainly tankers that are part of Russia's shadow fleet and are circumventing the price cap on Russian crude oil and petroleum products or transporting military goods for Russia or stolen grain from Ukraine," the Swiss statement said.Trusted news and daily delights, right in your inboxSee for yourself — The Yodel is the go-to source for daily news, entertainment and feel-good stories.The sanctioned individuals will be barred from entering Switzerland.In line with EU policy, […]
SWAT team responds to Mission warehouse in barricade incident
San Francisco police officers descended on the Mission District on Saturday morning, responding to a burglary that had turned into a barricade situation.No one was injured, and the incident resolved shortly after 1 p.m. after the suspect was arrested “without further incident” and taken to the hospital for “medical evaluation,” the department said.A source with knowledge of the situation said the suspect broke into a UCSF building and barricaded the door, leading to the SWAT call. The man yelled at the officers and then went to sleep, the source said. He surrendered as soon as the SWAT team forced entry.At 8:59 a.m., officers arrived at 20th and Alabama streets after a call regarding a nearby burglary, according to the San Francisco Police Department. At some point, the suspect barricaded in a warehouse complex at the intersection. At least a dozen […]
Suspect arrested in the killing of a woman who was set on fire on a NYC subway car
New York police have arrested a suspect accused of killing a female subway passenger by setting her on fire Sunday morning, according to police.Around 7:30 a.m., the suspect approached the victim on a train car and intentionally set her on fire before fleeing the scene, according to the NYPD.The suspect and the victim were both riding an F train to the end of the line at Stillwell Avenue in Brooklyn, according to NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch.Police believe the suspect used a lighter to ignite the victim’s clothing, “which became fully engulfed in a matter of seconds,” Tisch said.Police officers conducting a routine patrol at the station encountered the victim on fire inside a subway car, NYPD Det. Austin Glickman told CNN.Officials extinguished the fire, and EMS responded to the scene and pronounced the female dead, according to the police.“Unbeknownst to […]
Timeless
Timeless Source: missionlocal.org
“My son was murdered in case of mistaken identity
The heartbroken mum of a teen murdered in a case of mistaken identity described the moment she found out her son had died - and how she couldn’t “protect him”. Nikki Knight’s son, Mason Rist, 15, and his friend, Max Dixon, 16, were “hunted down” and stabbed in a “revenge attack” after being wrongly identified as culprits of an earlier incident. The two pals were on their way to get a pizza when Anthony Snook, 45, arrived in his Audi with Riley Tolliver, 18, Kodi Wescott, 17, and two teenagers, aged 15, 16 and 17, who cannot be named for legal reasons. CCTV footage - from Nikki's house - captured the horrific 33 second attack which began when four youth jump of the vehicle on Mason's doorstep, just metres from her the family home in Knowle, Bristol, where he grew […]
Related
Waymo rolls toward San Francisco Airport — showdown brewing
On Friday morning, a driverless Waymo vehicle, for reasons unknown, rolled into a patch of wet cement on the grounds of Laguna Honda Hospital — and sank in. It was, for onlookers, a source of much mirth and cellphone picture-taking. A witness tells your humble narrator that the wet cement ought to have been better demarcated with barricades — but, also, that a human driver would never, ever have made this mistake. Two weeks prior, an official with San Francisco International Airport wrote to the Planning Department. “The City and County of San Francisco, by and through the San Francisco Airport Commission proposes to approve a permit allowing autonomous vehicle companies to map the roads at San Francisco International Airport, ” it read.“Under the Proposed Project, autonomous vehicle companies would be allowed to deploy up to two autonomous vehicles operated by human drivers to […]
SWAT team responds to Mission warehouse in barricade incident
San Francisco police officers descended on the Mission District on Saturday morning, responding to a burglary that had turned into a barricade situation.No one was injured, and the incident resolved shortly after 1 p.m. after the suspect was arrested “without further incident” and taken to the hospital for “medical evaluation,” the department said.A source with knowledge of the situation said the suspect broke into a UCSF building and barricaded the door, leading to the SWAT call. The man yelled at the officers and then went to sleep, the source said. He surrendered as soon as the SWAT team forced entry.At 8:59 a.m., officers arrived at 20th and Alabama streets after a call regarding a nearby burglary, according to the San Francisco Police Department. At some point, the suspect barricaded in a warehouse complex at the intersection. At least a dozen […]
Timeless
Timeless Source: missionlocal.org
Jim’s, Mission diner, will keep cooking under nonprofit ownership
Fear not, we won’t be missing the beloved green salsa at Jim’s Restaurant for some time — breakfast is here to stay. Mission Local has learned that the Mission Language and Vocational School will take over neighborhood mainstay Jim’s, which invited customers in today for its last day in business under current ownership. This afternoon, a line was seen reaching the corner of the building at 20th and Mission streets, and the diner had to take a waitlist for people to get in. Mission Language and Vocational School, a nonprofit that offers workforce development and small business supportive services, will staff the restaurant with graduates from its catering program and culinary school. The nonprofit will keep on Beto, the longtime cook. The owners, husband and wife Kim Ok Un and Kim Jung Nyun, are retiring. MLVS is expected to take over the restaurant […]
Hawk on the house
Hawk on the house Source: missionlocal.org
Jim’s owners retiring, leaving future of Mission diner unclear
The mom-and-pop owners of Jim’s Restaurant on Mission Street, a community staple for over three decades, will have their last day of work this Saturday, according to the restaurant.Jim’s Restaurant announced that its owners will be retiring after Saturday. It’s unclear, however, whether Jim’s will continue operating under new management. What is clear is it will no longer be the same without Ms. and Mr. Kim. The current owners, Kim Ok Un and Kim Jung Nyun, declined to comment about their retirement or whether Jim’s would continue operating. An Instagram commenter says, “So so sooo happy for you guys!! So well deserved but Jim’s will never be the same without you”.Another says, “Legendary spot just up the street from KPOO. Thanks y’all for the decades of service to the community.”On Friday around noon, the restaurant at 2420 Mission St. between 20th and […]
