Background

As Statewide Eviction Protections Expire, SF Measure Kicks In

Article arrow_drop_down


Although a state measure to prevent evictions for tenants with pending rent relief applications expired Thursday, some tenants in San Francisco and Los Angeles counties saw a glimmer of hope as previously voided local protections kicked back in.

“The state’s decision to let the last of its emergency eviction protections expire prioritizes big landlords and real estate industry profits over stabilizing the low-income households and communities of color most impacted by the pandemic,” said Molly Goldberg, director of the San Francisco Anti-Displacement Coalition. She cited language and access barriers, in addition to ending the application period and preempting local evictions in March.

The state said that it has paid out “completed eligible applications,” though an additional 6,000 applications are pending due to applicants being unresponsive to requests for additional documentation, said Geoffrey Ross, deputy of federal financial assistance at the Department of Housing and Community Development. Advocates and some tenants who have been deemed “unresponsive” pointed to language barriers in communications as a reason why certain households have not responded within the desired time period.

However, San Francisco officials’ understanding is that these payments may take an additional three to four weeks to reach landlords, said Audrey Abadilla, a spokesperson for the Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development. The city is concerned about the delay’s impact on residents, small landlords and affordable housing providers, she said, and continues to urge the state “to exercise the greatest amount of urgency and flexibility in the approval and payment of CA COVID-19 Rent Relief applications.”

Though the 6,000 households with incomplete pending applications and denied tenants awaiting decisions on appeals are still vulnerable to eviction, cities and advocates hope the enactment of new protections will help to fill the gap for struggling tenants facing eviction for rent due after June 30.

Under Assembly Bill 2179, landlords could not evict a tenant with COVID-19 hardships for unpaid rent due between April 1, 2020, and March 31, 2022, as long as the tenant had applied for rent relief by the deadline and had not been denied. The bill also preempted eviction protections passed by local governments after Aug. 20, 2020, voiding protections unanimously passed by the San Francisco Board of Supervisors and signed into law by Mayor London Breed in March.

The preemption on local protections expired Thursday, allowing San Francisco’s March legislation to take effect Friday. Tenants in the city can no longer be evicted for nonpayment of rent due on or after July 1 until the city’s declared state of emergency ends, but the protections have a gap for back rent due from April 1 to June 30.

“The state has no longer stepped up and it’s up to the cities and counties to step up and do so,” said Ora Prochovnik, director of litigation and policy at the Eviction Defense Collaborative. “And those that haven’t, their residents will definitely be harmed.”

A coalition of tenants’ research, advocacy and legal groups called on local and state lawmakers on Tuesday to take action to prevent the evictions of tenants waiting for their applications to be paid out or their appeals to be processed. The group included the National Equity Atlas, Housing Now! and Western Center on Law & Poverty speakers, in addition to applicants to the program who were waiting on funds.

“How am I supposed to move forward from this? Am I gonna go live with Governor Newsom in his guest house?” asked Patricia Mendoza of Imperial City, a single mother of two. Mendoza, who spoke through tears at times, said she applied for assistance once and was approved, but has now been waiting five months for funds after reapplying for $9,000 in assistance. She has received an eviction notice from her landlord and said that it’s been very stressful and unstable for her and her children, one of whom is in seventh grade.

“I urge everyone to please think of us tenants,” she said.  

The California Apartment Association is urging members to hold off on evicting tenants with pending applications, as the money for qualifying tenants should be arriving soon and the onus is on rental assistance program administrators to make this happen, said Debra Carlton, executive vice president of state public affairs at the California Apartment Association.

Researchers and advocates have been warning of the potential for an eviction wave with the expiration of protections.

Old protections and new vulnerabilities

The state closed the doors to new applications on March 31 while extending eviction protections to June 30. That gave the department of Housing and Community Development three months to process outstanding applications so tenants waiting on relief would not be evicted while awaiting a decision.

“It would be cruel, wasteful and unfair to subject Californians to eviction for loss of rental income now, when they have done everything asked of them by filing and completing their application,” Assembly member and co-author of AB 2179 Tim Grayson, a Democrat from Concord, told the state Senate before it voted to extend protections on March 31.

Assembly member Buffy Wicks, a co-author and Democrat from Oakland, did not share why she and other legislators failed to extend protections for the tenants waiting on aid who are now at risk. She did note that qualified tenants who submitted applications by the deadline will receive assistance, and that local governments are able to enact eviction protections now that statewide protections have expired.

The state’s rent relief program has paid over 339,000 households close to $4 billion in assistance, according to the California COVID-19 Rent Relief Dashboard.

Previously, tenants whose applications were denied had 30 days to appeal the decision, which could stay an eviction. However, with the expiration of protections, tenants can appeal but are no longer protected from eviction until a final decision is made — even if the program eventually rules in their favor.

Close to one in three applications statewide had been denied as of June 23.

Sarah Treuhaft, vice president of Research at PolicyLink, said denials jumped from 20% when the program stopped accepting applications to close to 33% as of June 23, calling the rise a “huge concern.” She also noted that 93% of denials were for low-income applicants.

“Given the program increased in ability to process applications, there was an increase in approvals and denials as all applications were actively case managed,” said Ross of the state housing agency in response to questions about the increase in denials.

The Department of Housing and Community Development is facing multiple lawsuits related to the program. The most recent one, filed in June, critiques the program’s lack of transparency, especially regarding the reason for denials and cites a disproportionate harm to tenants based on race, color and national origin.

New local protections

AB 2179’s preemption on local protections was heavily criticized by tenants’ rights groups. Sen. Scott Wiener and Assembly person Phil Ting, both representatives of San Francisco, were the only two lawmakers to vote against the bill, citing the preemption.

“We are thrilled that the city has done what it can to protect its residents by putting this protection in place,” Prochovnik of the Eviction Defense Collaborative said, adding that cities cannot provide certain aspects of the state’s protections related to court procedures.

Due to the previous preemptions, the city’s legislation only protects tenants from eviction for rental debt incurred after July 1, 2022. Thus, if a San Francisco tenant could not pay rent in April when the state’s rent relief program had closed to new requests, they could be evicted for failure to pay, but a tenant who was unable to pay rent due in July would be protected.

“The unfairness is palpable,” Prochovnik said.   

The Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development reopened its own rent relief program for applications on April 1 after the state closed its program, and as of June 24 had made close to $2.9 million in relief payments to 504 of the 3,467 households that have applied.

The city continues to coordinate efforts to keep tenants housed through its rent relief program, eviction defense system and legal assistance program, said Abadilla, the Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development spokesperson.

San Francisco tenants are entitled to legal aid in eviction cases under the city’s universal right to counsel program — the first of its kind in the country and the only program of its type in the state.

Abadilla encouraged tenants who received an eviction notice to call, email or visit the Eviction Defense Collaborative. Those who are behind on rent should apply for San Francisco’s rent relief program.



Source: www.sfpublicpress.org

About the author

trending_flat
Man loses 300 lbs by walking and cutting this 1 food from his diet

Welcome to Start TODAY. Sign up for our Start TODAY newsletter to receive daily inspiration sent to your inbox — and join us on Instagram!About 25 years ago, Rick Salewske weighed 538 pounds. “When I was gaining weight, my world just got smaller and smaller. I couldn’t fit in chairs. I couldn’t go to restaurants. My knees hurt. The steering wheel in my car hit my stomach. I couldn’t put on my shoes. I quit going to college because I couldn’t fit in the desk,” he tells TODAY.com.In 2000, three things happened that motivated him to change:He dreamed that he died, and saw his brothers and sisters lowering him into the ground.He skipped his 20th high school reunion because he hadn’t seen his classmates over the years, and he was embarrassed about his weight.He got hired for a new job, over the phone, […]

trending_flat
‘Like a teddy bear’: Bob Lee’s friends testify to drug use, character

Two former colleagues and friends of Cash App founder Bob Lee testified today that while the homicide victim used drugs, Lee was not aggressive or erratic. The testimony countered a narrative from his alleged killer that Lee first drew the knife that killed him. Nima Momeni, the man on trial for Lee’s murder, has testified that Lee attacked him with a kitchen knife over a “bad joke,” about spending more time with his family rather than going to a strip club and that Momeni redirected the weapon toward Lee. Momeni’s defense team rested its case earlier this week. Prosecutors today called three rebuttal witnesses to testify to Lee’s character, as well as a San Francisco police captain intended to discredit a former sergeant who on Tuesday testified in support of the plausibility of Momeni’s self-defense claim. Kristina Champion, who worked with Lee when […]

trending_flat
Over 900 mobile home owners in Sweetwater, Florida handed move-out notices amid plans to transform park

Over 900 mobile home owners in Sweetwater, Florida handed move-out notices amid plans to transform park Residents of Li'l Abner Mobile Home Park in Sweetwater, Florida, were recently notified that they'll need to find somewhere else to live and quickly. The community of more than 900 mobile homes, together housing roughly 2,000 to 3,000 people per the mayor's estimate, will close in May 2025 to make way for new affordable and workforce housing. Mobile home owners usually own the home but rent the land it stands on. The land owner in this case, CREI Holdings, says it will provide a financial incentive of $14,000 to residents who leave by January 31, 2025. Those who leave by March 31 or April 30, will receive $7,000 and $3,000, respectively, though many tenants say it's not enough time or money, according to a […]

trending_flat
Judge denies motion to ease house arrest of Jon Jacobo

A San Francisco judge on Thursday denied a motion to loosen the home detention conditions forJon Jacobo, a once-rising star in San Francisco’s politics who was arrested on Aug. 5 for alleged sexual assault. “The motion is denied to the extent that it asks for relief from home detention and [ankle] monitoring,” said San Francisco Superior Court judge Kenneth Wine this morning. “It’s the seriousness of the charges that’s really driving my decision. There are a number of victims with very serious charges.”Jacobo, a longtime Mission District community leader, was first publicly accused of rape in 2021. This April, he resigned from his executive position at affordable-housing developer TODCO, soon after three women accused him of rape and abuse in a San Francisco Standard story. He was arrested on Aug. 5, 2024. Jacobo today showed up in the courtroom in casual clothes […]

trending_flat
Pam Bondi named as new AG pick after Gaetz drops out

Former Rep. Matt Gaetz, President-elect Donald Trump's pick for attorney general, said Thursday he is withdrawing his name for the role -- just a day after Gaetz spoke with Republican senators on Capitol Hill about the nomination process.Trump has named Pam Bondi, the former attorney general of Florida, as his new pick for the role.Another controversial Cabinet pick, Pete Hegseth, is on the Hill on Thursday with Vice President-elect JD Vance to make his case for the secretary of the Department of Defense job.Meanwhile, Trump continues to announce his picks for top jobs inside his administration.Latest DevelopmentsNov 21, 6:56 PMTrump nominates Pam Bondi as new AG pickTrump has nominated Pam Bondi as his new pick for attorney general, after Matt Gaetz withdrew from consideration earlier Thursday.Bondi is the former attorney general of Florida, serving from 2011 to 2019 and marking […]

trending_flat
Mission Local bags two Society of Professional Journalists awards

This here publication last week took home two more awards from the Northern California branch of the Society of Professional Journalists for in-depth coverage and analysis of the sort you expect — and demand — of us. Senior editor Joe Rivano Barros and former data reporter Will Jarrett were honored in the “Explanatory Journalism” category for the mammoth effort of tracing and documenting the Russian dolls-like series of interconnected organizations funneling billionaires’ dollars into San Francisco politics. Joe Rivano Barros, who with Will Jarrett won for the Big Money SF work. Photo by Abigail Van NeelyThe series, titled “BigMoneySF,” included Rivano Barros’ profile of Neighbors for a Better San Francisco, the largest donor over the last several election cycles, and Jarrett’s interactive chart, a stunning accomplishment requiring months of work unearthing reams of financial data structured in a manner so as to render it […]

Related

trending_flat
‘Like a teddy bear’: Bob Lee’s friends testify to drug use, character

Two former colleagues and friends of Cash App founder Bob Lee testified today that while the homicide victim used drugs, Lee was not aggressive or erratic. The testimony countered a narrative from his alleged killer that Lee first drew the knife that killed him. Nima Momeni, the man on trial for Lee’s murder, has testified that Lee attacked him with a kitchen knife over a “bad joke,” about spending more time with his family rather than going to a strip club and that Momeni redirected the weapon toward Lee. Momeni’s defense team rested its case earlier this week. Prosecutors today called three rebuttal witnesses to testify to Lee’s character, as well as a San Francisco police captain intended to discredit a former sergeant who on Tuesday testified in support of the plausibility of Momeni’s self-defense claim. Kristina Champion, who worked with Lee when […]

trending_flat
Judge denies motion to ease house arrest of Jon Jacobo

A San Francisco judge on Thursday denied a motion to loosen the home detention conditions forJon Jacobo, a once-rising star in San Francisco’s politics who was arrested on Aug. 5 for alleged sexual assault. “The motion is denied to the extent that it asks for relief from home detention and [ankle] monitoring,” said San Francisco Superior Court judge Kenneth Wine this morning. “It’s the seriousness of the charges that’s really driving my decision. There are a number of victims with very serious charges.”Jacobo, a longtime Mission District community leader, was first publicly accused of rape in 2021. This April, he resigned from his executive position at affordable-housing developer TODCO, soon after three women accused him of rape and abuse in a San Francisco Standard story. He was arrested on Aug. 5, 2024. Jacobo today showed up in the courtroom in casual clothes […]

trending_flat
Mission Local bags two Society of Professional Journalists awards

This here publication last week took home two more awards from the Northern California branch of the Society of Professional Journalists for in-depth coverage and analysis of the sort you expect — and demand — of us. Senior editor Joe Rivano Barros and former data reporter Will Jarrett were honored in the “Explanatory Journalism” category for the mammoth effort of tracing and documenting the Russian dolls-like series of interconnected organizations funneling billionaires’ dollars into San Francisco politics. Joe Rivano Barros, who with Will Jarrett won for the Big Money SF work. Photo by Abigail Van NeelyThe series, titled “BigMoneySF,” included Rivano Barros’ profile of Neighbors for a Better San Francisco, the largest donor over the last several election cycles, and Jarrett’s interactive chart, a stunning accomplishment requiring months of work unearthing reams of financial data structured in a manner so as to render it […]

trending_flat
‘Slow Streets, Fast Friends’ mural comes to 20th St. in the Mission

Sign up below to get Mission Local’s free newsletter, a daily digest of news you won’t find elsewhere. Josue Rojas hovers in the air above the ground, gingerly balancing his stomach on a stool while holding his paintbrush in one hand, face towards the asphalt. He says it’s better than being on all fours. “It’s particularly brutal work,” says Rojas. “I’m on my knees six to eight hours a day and, now that I’m in my mid-40s, it’s not that easy to bear.” Rojas has spent the past week working between bursts of rain to create a street mural on 20th and Florida streets for the “Slow Streets, Fast Friends” project of the SF Parks Alliance nonprofit, which commissions murals on slow streets throughout the city.The mural was finished this past weekend, and now adorns the block where Atlas Cafe, the Southern […]

trending_flat
SFMTA board approves new Valencia bikeway—but few are happy

The San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency’s board unanimously approved the new curbside Valencia Street bike lane on Tuesday, and admitted that the transit agency should have been more cautious with experiments in merchant corridors.That experiment — a bike lane running up the center of the street — had pitted transit advocates against shopkeepers. Now cyclists and the Valencia Corridor Merchants Association were finally on the same page: Neither were fans of the new design.“The [merchants association] cannot officially support the side-running bike lane,” said Manny Yekutiel, president of the Valencia Corridor Merchants Association, which has fought the old design. Yekutiel was one of dozens who spoke up in the three-hour-long meeting held at City Hall.Yekutiel, echoing long-held concerns from merchants against streetscape changes, said the new design will get rid of a lot of the parking spots on Valencia Street. […]

About Karl The Fog

Welcome to Karl The Fog, your digital gateway to the enigmatic world of San Francisco’s legendary mist. We are the storytellers, the observers, and the chroniclers of the ever-elusive, charismatic character known as Karl.

KARL THE FOG, and KARL THE FOG COFFEE logos, images, fonts, names, and other trademarks are trademarks of KARL THE FOG, LLC and may not be used without permission.

Login to enjoy full advantages

Please login or subscribe to continue.

Go Premium!

Enjoy the full advantage of the premium access.

Stop following

Unfollow Cancel

Cancel subscription

Are you sure you want to cancel your subscription? You will lose your Premium access and stored playlists.

Go back Confirm cancellation