Background

Aaron Peskin didn’t win the election. But his propositions sure did.

Article arrow_drop_down


San Francisco Board of Supervisors president, mayoral candidate, and wildly prolific legislator Aaron Peskin lost the election to Daniel Lurie, a wealthy candidate with zero legislative experience.

But his three main ballot initiatives are winning and will, barring unforeseen lunacy, pass into legislation. Here’s the story of how they made it. 

Prop. C

Creating a position for an inspector general with the power to investigate government and city contractor fraud, waste, abuse or misconduct would seem like a tough measure to oppose. It didn’t require any new funding, every single member of the Board of Supervisors voted to put it on the ballot, and corruption scandals have been breaking at a steady clip for years. But GrowSF, TogetherSF Action and the San Francisco Democratic Party all came out against it. 

It got 60 percent of the preliminary vote anyway. Partly that’s because Peskin did a good job getting the word out, says Jim Stearns, a consultant to many progressive campaigns including Peskin’s mayoral bid. Peskin is enough of a policy wonk that he had more plans for improving the functioning of city government than he could cram into any one appearance. His six-point plan to reduce homelessness was more like an 11 million point plan. But he brought up the inspector general every time he made a campaign speech.  

Their opposition to Prop. C speaks to a larger problem for Together SF, Grow SF, and the other groups that have been spending big on local elections, says Stearns. When they issue endorsements they’re trying to mimic local progressive groups whose endorsements have real sway — like the Harvey Milk Democratic Club. But unlike those groups, they don’t have a voting membership, and the process by which they make endorsements isn’t transparent and feels highly personal and idiosyncratic. Why paper the city with ads complaining about city corruption in support of Prop. D, but not support Prop. C? At any rate, says Stearns, the voters didn’t buy it — Prop. C is passing with ease, in spite of minimal funding.

Prop. E

Prop. E was created by Peskin’s office in response to Prop. D — a ballot measure, created and lavishly funded by Together SF, that would have given the mayor power to eliminate entire advisory boards and commissions as well as weakening civilian oversight of the Police Commission, under the guise of making city government more efficient. Michael Moritz, the local billionaire who poured at least $3.2 million of his money into Prop. D, described the measure as  “the greatest gift anybody has given to a mayor in the recent history of San Francisco.” 

Like Prop. D, Proposition E also proposed to streamline the city’s admittedly commission-heavy structure — but via an independent blue-ribbon panel that will make any changes within a system of public hearings. Supporters of Prop. E. had less than 1 percent of the money that Prop. D did, says Doug Engmann, former president of the Planning Commission. What they had instead was a network of good government types who were horrified at the potential consequences of Prop. D and who began working together to place op-eds in local publications explaining the risks posed by it. “We spread the network rapidly,” says Engmann. “You can see it in the ballot handbook. Within a month, we had more endorsements from prestigious organizations than they did.” No less than the San Francisco Bar Association came out against Prop. D. 

The No on D Yes on E crowd was also aided by mayoral candidate Mark Farrell’s decision to create a PAC in support of Prop. D and commingle its funds with his mayoral committee — which resulted in a $108,000 ethics penalty announced the day before the election. That was the coup de grâce to a long slide downward in public opinion and, as Farrell struggled, he took Prop. D down with him. Think about it, says Engmannn: If you got 16 flyers from Mark Farrell saying “Vote Yes on D” and every day you read more about Mark Farrell and his ethics violations, Prop. D does not look good. “He did all of the advertising for us!” says Engmann. 

A flyer promoting Prop D features a man in a suit, Mark Farrell, who supports eliminating bureaucracy. The flyer includes quotes endorsing Prop D and lists donations from four individuals.
The back of the Mark Farrell ad. Photo by Xueer Lu. September 13, 2024.

Prop. E remains a close call — it is receiving a bit over 51 percent of the early vote, but its margins are growing with each subsequent ballot drop. But 55 percent of voters have said No on Prop. D, and it continues to drop. It was a new milestone for Stearns. ”I’ve never been out-spent $8 million to $80,000 and won,” he says, laughing. (The amount spent in support of D is, at last count, $9,522,242).



Source: missionlocal.org

About the author

trending_flat
Few new votes, but Chyanne Chen keeps lead in District 11

The San Francisco Department of Elections just dropped the results of another 1,679 ballots, bringing the total of processed ballots to 390,437 — 74.76 percent of the electorate.Even though the count has been going slow so far this week, John Arntz, the director of the Department of Elections told Mission Local on Monday that they will “have most of the remaining ballot cards processed and reported this week.” San Francisco is seeing a record-low turnout this year with the total tracking to be about 77.8 percent. The average San Francisco turnout in a presidential year, going back 108 years, is 77 percent. All eyes are now on the only two remaining contested races: District 11 supervisor, and the fourth and last seat on the Board of Education:In District 11, Chyanne Chen kept up with her lead with 11,863 votes to her moderate […]

trending_flat
S&P 500 target, outlook on Trump-Musk DOGE cuts: Market Domination

US stocks (^DJI, ^IXIC, ^GSPC) are reacting to this morning's Consumer Price Index (CPI) print, which saw prices rising in line with economist projections for October. Julie Hyman and Josh Lipton tackle the day's biggest market stories on today's Market Domination. Oppenheimer Asset Management chief investment strategist John Stoltzfus outlines the catalysts he is seeing that could push the S&P 500 (^GSPC) to 6,200 by 2024's end. Citi chief US economist Andrew Hollenhorst and Tufts University Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy professor Gautam Mukunda both comment on what President-elect Trump's Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) initiative could look like under the helm of Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy. To watch more expert insights and analysis on the latest market action, check out more Market Domination here. Other top trending stocks on the Yahoo Finance platform include Rocket Lab USA […]

trending_flat
Visit Chestnut Hill, PA For Holidays on the Hill

  On any typical day, with its historic cobblestone streets, elegant mansions, Victorian townhomes, and a quaint walkable shopping row, Chestnut Hill, PA  is pretty charming. But what most people don’t know is that nine miles northwest of Center City, Philadelphia, this picture-perfect “Garden District” quietly transforms itself into a Hallmark worthy Christmas village for its “Holidays on the Hill” event each year.  With festive events running through the end of December, you’ll find many holiday themed things to see and do in Philly’s safest neighborhood.   See twinkling lights, festive decorations, and creative window displays while shopping at over 60 unique boutiques in celebration of the season. When you get hungry, there’s a variety of restaurants, cafes and bakeries in Chestnut Hill that provide indoor and heated outdoor seating options, whether you’re looking for a full satisfying meal or just […]

trending_flat
SF immigration advocates prepare for Trump administration 

San Francisco’s status as a sanctuary city places it in the bullseye for an attack from an emboldened Donald Trump administration. This time, however, lawyers and community advocates have seen the playbook, and have already begun steeling themselves. “This is the second time around … and he’s got more ideas, apparently,” said Bill Hing, the founding director of the University of San Francisco’s Immigration and Deportation Defense Clinic. “So we have got to prepare for the worst.”Changes to the immigration systemHing predicts immigration advocates will face both ideological and procedural challenges. Take domestic violence cases, for example. People escaping domestic violence currently make up the majority of cases successfully handled by Hing’s clinic. These cases will soon become more difficult to win, as Hing expects the federal attorney general appointed by Trump will hold a narrower definition of what justifies political asylum that […]

trending_flat
Vietnam Airlines to request bids for 50 narrowbody jets next year

BANDAR SERI BEGAWAN (Reuters) -Vietnam Airlines will issue requests for proposals to aircraft manufacturers next year to purchase 50 narrowbody jets, its CEO said on Wednesday. The carrier last year signed a provisional deal with Boeing for 50 737 MAX planes that has yet to be finalised. "In Vietnam we have to go through the bidding process, we have to open to others... The door is still open for everyone," Vietnam Airlines CEO Le Hong Ha told Reuters on the sidelines of an Association of Asia-Pacific Airlines event in Brunei. "Boeing is one option, they have a very good offer for us." Airbus and Boeing are the main global manufacturers of single-aisle aircraft, with Airbus' A320neo family competing against the 737 MAX, though Chinese planemaker COMAC is trying to make inroads with its C919. Vietnam Airlines' current narrowbody fleet consists […]

trending_flat
Christmas in Peddlers Village – Bucks County, Pennsylvania

Updated 11/2024 with current information   Each year for the holidays, I venture somewhere a little extra special and take in the wonder of the season. Last Christmas we visited Berlin, Maryland – a sweet little historic town on Maryland’s eastern shore and a short drive from Ocean City. This year we wanted something a little closer to home. We headed to Peddler’s Village, a 42-acre, Colonial-style village in Bucks County, Pennsylvania. Considered one of the Philadelphia region’s most photogenic spots during the holidays, this sweet little country village has everything you’d want in a holiday winter wonderland. Things To Do In Peddler’s Village With over 65 boutiques, specialty shops, galleries, and restaurants, nestled around winding brick pathways, Peddler’s Village is a charming place to visit any time of year. But around the second week of November, Peddler’s Village comes alive […]

Related

trending_flat
Few new votes, but Chyanne Chen keeps lead in District 11

The San Francisco Department of Elections just dropped the results of another 1,679 ballots, bringing the total of processed ballots to 390,437 — 74.76 percent of the electorate.Even though the count has been going slow so far this week, John Arntz, the director of the Department of Elections told Mission Local on Monday that they will “have most of the remaining ballot cards processed and reported this week.” San Francisco is seeing a record-low turnout this year with the total tracking to be about 77.8 percent. The average San Francisco turnout in a presidential year, going back 108 years, is 77 percent. All eyes are now on the only two remaining contested races: District 11 supervisor, and the fourth and last seat on the Board of Education:In District 11, Chyanne Chen kept up with her lead with 11,863 votes to her moderate […]

trending_flat
SF immigration advocates prepare for Trump administration 

San Francisco’s status as a sanctuary city places it in the bullseye for an attack from an emboldened Donald Trump administration. This time, however, lawyers and community advocates have seen the playbook, and have already begun steeling themselves. “This is the second time around … and he’s got more ideas, apparently,” said Bill Hing, the founding director of the University of San Francisco’s Immigration and Deportation Defense Clinic. “So we have got to prepare for the worst.”Changes to the immigration systemHing predicts immigration advocates will face both ideological and procedural challenges. Take domestic violence cases, for example. People escaping domestic violence currently make up the majority of cases successfully handled by Hing’s clinic. These cases will soon become more difficult to win, as Hing expects the federal attorney general appointed by Trump will hold a narrower definition of what justifies political asylum that […]

trending_flat
Chyanne Chen’s slim lead grows — barely

The San Francisco Department of Elections moments ago released the results of an additional 6,466 ballots. That brings the grand total of processed ballots to 388,758 — 74.44 percent of the electorate.There are now very few ballots remaining — largely provisional ballots cast at citywide polling places and at City Hall. Today is also the last day for any mail ballot postmarked on Election Day or earlier to reach City Hall and be counted. All told, 18,200 additional ballots remain uncounted, including 14,500 provisional ones. Verifying provisional ballots requires additional scrutiny — and, naturally, additional time.Turnout is tracking to be about 77.8 percent, maximum. The average San Francisco turnout in a presidential year, going back 108 years, is 77 percent. Around 43,000 fewer San Franciscans will have cast a ballot in 2024 than they did four years ago. There are only two remaining contested […]

trending_flat
District 1 Sup Connie Chan cruising to re-election; up by 1167 votes

Progressive District 1 supervisor Connie Chan is on track to defeat her moderate challenger Marjan Philhour, after today’s vote drop put her up by 1,167 votes at 51.75 percent. This likely concluded the most expensive supervisor race this year, as moderate groups saw Chan as particularly vulnerable because she beat Philhour by just 125 votes in their last contest in 2020. Almost $2.5 million was spent in the District 1 race. But it appears that Chan’s advantage has only improved. As of Nov. 11, Chan led, 17,232 to 16,065 after ranked-choice tabulation. About 34,000 votes were already counted in District 1. There were approximately 24,700 votes citywide to be counted, but the math is not there for Philhour. The race was expected to be extremely close — the two leading candidates were tied at 11,001 votes apiece after the Thursday results update — […]

trending_flat
Connie Chan, Myrna Melgar bound for victory.

The San Francisco Department of Elections moments ago released the results of an additional 17,333 ballots. That brings the grand total of processed ballots to 382,292 — 73.2 percent of the electorateThere are now very few ballots remaining — perhaps 24,700. Of those, 6,700 are late-arriving vote-by-mail ballots and some 18,000 are provisional ballots cast at citywide polling places (which may or may not ultimately be accepted). Turnout is tracking to be about 77.8 percent, maximum. The average San Francisco turnout in a presidential year, going back 108 years, is 77 percent. Around 43,000 fewer San Franciscans figure to have cast a ballot in 2024 than they did four years ago. On to the contested Board of Supervisors races: District 1 Supervisor Connie Chan takes a photo with supporters on Nov. 5, 2024. Photo by Junyao Yang. In District 1, Connie Chan now sits […]

trending_flat
Dean Preston concedes likely defeat in San Francisco’s District 5

Tech entrepreneur and “YIMBY” candidate Bilal Mahmood is poised to unseat District 5 supervisor Dean Preston, San Francisco’s only democratic socialist now serving on the board. In the most expensive district race, political opposition groups lavishly funded the effort to “Dump Dean.”  Though some 42,000 additional citywide votes are still uncounted, Preston on Sunday evening acknowledged his dwindling chances to mitigate his vote deficit and seemed to concede the race.“I’ve spent a lifetime fighting for underdogs, often against the odds,” Preston said in a statement to Mission Local. “I wouldn’t change a minute of it. We can’t win every battle, but we’ll continue the fight.”Though Preston has continued to gain on Mahmood in first-place votes, Mahmood has maintained a lead when ranked-choice selections are counted, putting him more than 1,300 votes ahead of Preston with 52.7 percent.  “I think it’s representative of […]

Be the first to leave a comment

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Karl The Fog

Welcome to Karl The Fog, your digital gateway to the enigmatic world of San Francisco’s legendary mist. We are the storytellers, the observers, and the chroniclers of the ever-elusive, charismatic character known as Karl.

KARL THE FOG, and KARL THE FOG COFFEE logos, images, fonts, names, and other trademarks are trademarks of KARL THE FOG, LLC and may not be used without permission.

Login to enjoy full advantages

Please login or subscribe to continue.

Go Premium!

Enjoy the full advantage of the premium access.

Stop following

Unfollow Cancel

Cancel subscription

Are you sure you want to cancel your subscription? You will lose your Premium access and stored playlists.

Go back Confirm cancellation