Background

Before Implosion, “Titan ”Pilot and CEO Had Panicked Meltdown When He Crashed Into a Shipwreck: Ex-Employee

Article arrow_drop_down


“It was unprofessional behavior of him, he started to panic,” David Lochridge testified of Stockton Rush

<p>Wilfredo Lee/AP; Getty</p><p>Wilfredo Lee/AP; Getty</p>

Years before he piloted the Titan submersible more than 2 miles beneath the surface of the Northern Atlantic Ocean on a doomed voyage to see the wreckage of the Titanic, Stockton Rush took another small group of passengers to see another famed ship beneath the waves — but fell into “panic” due to a lack of experience, a former employee claims.

David Lochridge, who worked as operations director at OceanGate, which Rush co-founded and ran as CEO, testified on Tuesday, Sept. 17, at an ongoing U.S. Coast Guard hearing about the implosion of Titan while on its way to the Titanic last summer, killing all five people aboard, including Rush.

Lochridge did not mince words about his views on Rush or OceanGate.

“The whole idea behind the company was to make money,” he said at one point. “That’s it.”

He was no less blunt in recounting a previous voyage, reportedly in 2016, in which Rush insisted on piloting another of OceanGate’s submersibles, called the Cyclops 1, down to see the remains of the Andrea Doria ocean liner.

Lochridge said he had expected to be the pilot, as the “most experienced” such member of OceanGate’s team.

“Unfortunately, the CEO decided that he wanted to take it down,” Lochridge said. “I objected because I knew sometimes he could do things to please himself.”

But, according to Lochridge, Rush essentially pulled rank: “Just remember I’m the CEO, you’re just an employee.”

At Lochridge’s urging, Rush let him still join the trip on the Cyclops, along with three paying passengers, Lochridge said.

Almost immediately, however, there were issues, according to his testimony.

Related: Final Message from Doomed Titan Sub Revealed, Sent Seconds Before Losing Contact with the Surface

<p>Wilfredo Lee/AP; Getty</p> Stockton Rush (left) and the Andrea Doria<p>Wilfredo Lee/AP; Getty</p> Stockton Rush (left) and the Andrea Doria

Wilfredo Lee/AP; Getty

Stockton Rush (left) and the Andrea Doria

Rush ignored concerns about the weather, and how the currents in the Atlantic, off the coast of Massachusetts, were buffeting the dive platform to and fro.

Later, Rush, at the helm of the Cyclops, struggled to begin the dive, Lochridge said: “He attempted to take it off, he didn’t do it very well.”

As they descended, Lochridge said, he reminded Rush that they had planned to keep some distance from the wreckage because of the danger it poses to divers who get too close. But Rush rebuffed him, he said, with “don’t tell me what to do.”

The Andrea Doria lies relatively close to the surface, only about 250 feet deep — compared to the Titanic, at 2-plus miles — and the Cyclops crew had a “clear sonar image,” Lochridge said.

Still, Rush “smashed straight down on the bottom,” seriously limiting visibility, as two of the passengers remarked, “Oh my god, we are right on the wreck,” Lochridge said.

Lochridge advised Rush to assess their surroundings and wait for better visibility before continuing the journey, “which is standard practice for any competent submersible pilot,” he said.

“He just kept arguing with me in the sub, very unbecoming of a submersible pilot,” Lochridge testified. “I’m trying to give the best course of action to get him out of it, [but Rush responded with], ‘No matter what, I’m doing this.’ “

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. 

Rush then decided to do an unusual maneuver, Lochridge said, turning the Cyclops about 180 degrees while moving and ended up going “full speed into the port side of the bow and we could hear the cracking … as he got us jammed in underneath.”

“I’m not going to say how foul my language was,” Lochridge told Coast Guard investigators on Tuesday, “but it wasn’t good.”

“At that point, it was unprofessional behavior of him, he started to panic and the first thing was [asking], ‘Do we have enough life support on board?’ “ Lochridge said, remembering what happened next. “I was like, ‘Stockton of course we have enough life support. We need to get out of here.’ “

Rush asked about getting a support dive team from the surface to help, but Lochridge asked to take the controls, he said. Instead, Rush just kept repeating, “We’re stuck, we’re stuck, we’re stuck,” Lochridge said.

“Every time I went to take the controller from him, he pushed it further and further behind him,” he testified of Rush. (Elsewhere in his testimony, he commented wryly on the widely discussed fact that OceanGate submersibles were controlled via Playstation controller.)

Lochridge said that during the dive to the Andrea Doria, while he had gone to look out into the ocean, from inside the sub, to assess the situation, Rush “never once got out of the seat in the back of the sub.”

“Eventually it took one of the paying clients … she shouted at Stockton to ‘give me the f—ing controller.’ She had tears in her eyes,” Lochridge said.

Rush obliged, in his way, Lochridge said: He threw the controller at Lochridge and it “clattered it off the right side of my head,” then hit the ground and “one of the buttons came off.” (“Robust,” he quipped of the technology.)

Lochridge said he quickly fixed the controller, took the helm and “had us out 10-15 minutes.”

<p>Xinhua/Shutterstock</p> The Titan submersible<p>Xinhua/Shutterstock</p> The Titan submersible

Xinhua/Shutterstock

The Titan submersible

Once he had pulled the Cyclops back about 160 feet, he admonished Rush, “This is what we’re supposed to do,” he said.

Rush, he said, was apologetic, telling him, “I owe you one, anything I can do for you.”

Back at the surface, the others celebrated Lochridge for intervening, he said. But more importantly, more dangerously, he testified on Tuesday, “It shouldn’t have gotten to the stage it got to. If he [Rush] had in any way behaved like any other submersible pilot I know and looked at your surroundings, talked on the radio, on the communications, let the top-side know … he didn’t do it.”

Their relationship never recovered from that, Lochridge said.

“Because people were cheering and the passengers were obviously very grateful for what I did, which to me is just my job, at that point he stopped talking to me,” he said, “and it went on from there.”

In the wake of the Andrea Doria incident, Lochridge was “phased out of the project completely,” he testified. He said he had “embarrassed” Rush even if “I didn’t mean to.”

Publicly, Rush touted the Andrea Doria trip as a success.

He said in the press at the time that “given the conditions, we got as much time on the wreck as we could. We have great respect for harsh ocean conditions, and for the history of this infamous wreck, so ensuring the safety of our crew is always our top priority.”

Related: Photo Shows What Was Left of Titan Sub After Implosion as OceanGate Attorney Says ‘There Are No Words’

According to The New York Times, Lochridge was fired from OceanGate in 2018 as part of a falling-out after he expressed his concerns about the company’s approach to diving, in particular its development of the Titan sub.

Lochridge subsequently filed a complaint with the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, ABC News reported.

“It was inevitable something was going to happen, and it was just when,” he said on Tuesday.

Lochridge and OceanGate were tangled in dueling lawsuits that were later settled, the Times reported.

The Coast Guard this week opened what is expected to be a two-week hearing into the Titan implosion that will “review testimony from technical experts, crew members, and other relevant parties, and will examine evidence related to the submersible’s design, operation, and safety protocols,” the Coast Guard has said.

Afterward, investigators will submit a final report.

OceanGate has since suspended its operations amid the ongoing investigation into what happened.

According to the Associated Press, the company says it has cooperated fully with the government probes.

Attorney Jane Shvets, representing OceanGate at the hearing, read a brief opening statement on Monday, Sept. 16, in which she said they “offer our deepest condolences to the families and loved ones, among them those here today, of those who died on June 18, 2023.”

“There are no words to ease the loss endured by the families impacted by this tragic incident,” she said, “but we hope that this hearing will help shed light on the cause of the tragedy and prevent anything like this from happening again.”

For more People news, make sure to sign up for our newsletter!

Read the original article on People.



Source: www.yahoo.com

About the author

trending_flat
Gas leak shuts down 4 blocks in Mission, buildings evacuated

A gas leak near 24th and Hampshire streets in the Mission caused several buildings to be evacuated on Tuesday morning for about three hours, as emergency crews worked to find the source of the leak and shut it down. A four-block radius on Hampshire Street from 23rd to 25th streets and on 24th Street from Potrero Avenue to York Street was still shut down to vehicle traffic as of Tuesday afternoon, and emergency crews were on scene.Lt. Mariano Elias, a spokesperson for the San Francisco Fire Department, said the department got a 911 call from a construction worker at 9:15 a.m. about a broken gas pipe at the intersection. A private firm had been doing work that morning, Elias said, though he did not know the name of the firm.The crew struck a two-inch natural gas line at the intersection, […]

trending_flat
Nearly 100 still missing in North Carolina after Hurricane Helene

Ninety-two people are still unaccounted for in North Carolina, weeks after Hurricane Helene devastated the western part of the state, Governor Roy Cooper said on Tuesday.In a news conference on Tuesday, Cooper warned that number could change as more reports of missing people are resolved."I want to caution that this is not a definitive count, because the task force is continuing its work," he said.Ninety-five people are known to have died in North Carolina as a result of the storm, while more than 220 have been killed in total, including in Florida, where the storm made landfall.During the news conference, Cooper also made reference to the "persistent and dangerous flow of misinformation" circulating about the hurricane, which he said was continuing to complicate relief efforts.He said such misinformation "breeds confusion and demoralises storm survivors and response workers alike"."If you're participating […]

trending_flat
Murder trial for CashApp founder Bob Lee kicks off in San Francisco

During opening statements today in the highly anticipated murder trial of Nima Momeni, who is accused of stabbing CashApp founder Bob Lee to death last year, attorneys presented two different versions of events: One in which Momeni was a hostile aggressor, the other in which Lee was a drug-addled, sleep-deprived assailant. “Stabbed through his heart — and left to die,” Omid Talai, the lead prosecutor, said slowly and deliberately to the packed San Francisco Superior Courtroom, underscoring his version of events with images projected on two large screens of Lee’s lifeless and stitched-up body.He also showed the jury of seven men and five women surveillance footage of Lee’s movements in the hours before his death. Saam Zangeneh, the lead defense attorney, started with a similarly dramatic opening: “Six. Six hours,” he said. Evidence would show, he said, that Lee slept only six hours […]

trending_flat
A La Niña winter is coming. Here’s what that could mean for the US

Fall is in full swing, but it’s not too soon to look ahead to winter, especially one that could feel considerably different than last year’s dominated by El Niño.A weak La Niña is expected to develop ahead of the season and influence temperatures, precipitation, and by extension, even snow across the United States.La Niña is a natural climate pattern that influences global weather marked by cooler than average ocean temperatures in the equatorial Pacific. The effects on weather are most pronounced during the winter months in the Northern Hemisphere and have a much weaker influence in the summer.Last winter was the warmest on record for the Lower 48 because it was dominated by La Niña’s counterpart El Niño in a world also warming due to fossil fuel pollution.The prolonged warmth prevented many heavy snow events in the Northeast and Midwest and created […]

trending_flat
Thousands gather for Indigenous Peoples’ day on Alcatraz Island

Sign up below to get Mission Local’s free newsletter, a daily digest of news you won’t find elsewhere. While the rest of the city slept, Alcatraz glowed as thousands circled around a bonfire lit on the island in honor of Indigenous Peoples’ Day.The annual sunrise gathering began before dawn on Monday to commemorate the original occupation of Alcatraz island, the ancestral lands of the Ohlone, by “Indians of All Tribes” between 1969 and 1971. Organizers from the International Indian Treaty Council say that action “sparked the National and International Indigenous Peoples movement for rights and justice.”This year, the event drew around 2,500 people, council liaison Morning Star Gali estimated. The crowds did not shy away from an early morning boat ride. The council’s executive director, Andrea Carmen, arrived around 2:30 a.m to set up for the dozens of indigenous performers who […]

trending_flat
Q3 earnings focus is on price pressures: JPMorgan strategist

After the S&P 500 (^GSPC) and Dow Jones Industrial Average (^DJI) close at record highs, JPMorgan asset management global market strategist Jordan Jackson sits down with Market Domination Overtime Hosts Julie Hyman and Josh Lipton to discuss his view that tech stocks are likely to take a backseat this earnings season.The strategist expects CEOs and CFOs will "continue to have this sort of benign outlook." He tells Yahoo Finance, "It's not great, but it's not bad either. And so I think in this environment, they can still flex a little bit of pricing power. You can still see the earnings recovery kind of come through for other sectors outside of technology, which I think is really important for the durability of this market rally, right. So I think you know co confidence is going to again be sort of benign. […]

Related

trending_flat
Nearly 100 still missing in North Carolina after Hurricane Helene

Ninety-two people are still unaccounted for in North Carolina, weeks after Hurricane Helene devastated the western part of the state, Governor Roy Cooper said on Tuesday.In a news conference on Tuesday, Cooper warned that number could change as more reports of missing people are resolved."I want to caution that this is not a definitive count, because the task force is continuing its work," he said.Ninety-five people are known to have died in North Carolina as a result of the storm, while more than 220 have been killed in total, including in Florida, where the storm made landfall.During the news conference, Cooper also made reference to the "persistent and dangerous flow of misinformation" circulating about the hurricane, which he said was continuing to complicate relief efforts.He said such misinformation "breeds confusion and demoralises storm survivors and response workers alike"."If you're participating […]

trending_flat
A La Niña winter is coming. Here’s what that could mean for the US

Fall is in full swing, but it’s not too soon to look ahead to winter, especially one that could feel considerably different than last year’s dominated by El Niño.A weak La Niña is expected to develop ahead of the season and influence temperatures, precipitation, and by extension, even snow across the United States.La Niña is a natural climate pattern that influences global weather marked by cooler than average ocean temperatures in the equatorial Pacific. The effects on weather are most pronounced during the winter months in the Northern Hemisphere and have a much weaker influence in the summer.Last winter was the warmest on record for the Lower 48 because it was dominated by La Niña’s counterpart El Niño in a world also warming due to fossil fuel pollution.The prolonged warmth prevented many heavy snow events in the Northeast and Midwest and created […]

trending_flat
Q3 earnings focus is on price pressures: JPMorgan strategist

After the S&P 500 (^GSPC) and Dow Jones Industrial Average (^DJI) close at record highs, JPMorgan asset management global market strategist Jordan Jackson sits down with Market Domination Overtime Hosts Julie Hyman and Josh Lipton to discuss his view that tech stocks are likely to take a backseat this earnings season.The strategist expects CEOs and CFOs will "continue to have this sort of benign outlook." He tells Yahoo Finance, "It's not great, but it's not bad either. And so I think in this environment, they can still flex a little bit of pricing power. You can still see the earnings recovery kind of come through for other sectors outside of technology, which I think is really important for the durability of this market rally, right. So I think you know co confidence is going to again be sort of benign. […]

trending_flat
Two new casinos proposed just blocks apart in South Mississippi. Here are both plans

Developers have worked for years to build a new casino in east Biloxi and now two properties a few blocks from each other are going to the Mississippi Gaming Commission for site approval.“They’re two different casinos,” said Jay McDaniel, executive director of Mississippi Gaming Commission.Tullis Gardens Hotel and casino is just west of Harrah’s Gulf Coast.Biloxi Capital proposes building on the Tivoli a short walk away, near the Biloxi Yacht Club and Ohr-O’Keefe Museum of Art.The Tullis Garden Hotel request for site approval is on Thursday’s Gaming Commission agenda to be presented to the commission in Jackson, McDaniel said,The legal advertisement for Biloxi Capital’s site is running in the Sun Herald for the required three weeks, Oct. 2, 9 and 16, and then will be considered.Getting site approval from the three-member Gaming Commission is necessary to proceed with plans, but […]

trending_flat
Father sentenced to 55 years in prison for killing daughter over prom dispute

An Illinois father has been sentenced to more than five decades in prison for killing his 17-year-old daughter over a prom dispute, according to Illinois TV stations Fox 32 and WGN-9.[DOWNLOAD: Free WHIO-TV News app for alerts as news breaks]Mohammed Almaru, 44, was sentenced to 55 years in prison after being convicted of first-degree murder in connection to the death of his daughter, Mia Maro, in May 2022.TRENDING STORIES:Both stations report that Mohammed beat Maro to death after a disagreement over prom.At the time of her death, she was weeks away from graduating high school. She attended Victor Andrew High School, according to WGN-9.Court documents indicate that Almaru initially allowed Maro to go to the dance but changed his mind because “he did not trust her,” both stations report.In the days before her death, Maro reached out to a relative […]

trending_flat
1 Vanguard ETF to Buy Now, 1 to Avoid

One of the best innovations in investing has been the exchange-traded fund (ETF), an investment vehicle that lets anyone easily buy shares of a fund that holds a group of related stocks, often in an index.Vanguard founder Jack Bogle is credited with creating one of the first index funds, a mutual fund that paved the way for the popular Vanguard 500 Fund, which tracks the S&P 500.Today, Vanguard remains one of the most popular ETF managers and it offers investors dozens to choose from. Let's take a look at one worth investing in and one to avoid right now.Image source: Getty Images.One Vanguard ETF to buy nowThe Vanguard ETF worth buying right now is the Vanguard Financials ETF (NYSEMKT: VFH), which tracks the MSCI US benchmark of large, mid-, and small-cap stocks in the financial sector.Few ETFs are as cheap […]

About Karl The Fog

Welcome to Karl The Fog, your digital gateway to the enigmatic world of San Francisco’s legendary mist. We are the storytellers, the observers, and the chroniclers of the ever-elusive, charismatic character known as Karl.

KARL THE FOG, and KARL THE FOG COFFEE logos, images, fonts, names, and other trademarks are trademarks of KARL THE FOG, LLC and may not be used without permission.

Login to enjoy full advantages

Please login or subscribe to continue.

Go Premium!

Enjoy the full advantage of the premium access.

Stop following

Unfollow Cancel

Cancel subscription

Are you sure you want to cancel your subscription? You will lose your Premium access and stored playlists.

Go back Confirm cancellation